707 the ring of Akhaten - 超時空奇俠

過分不知所云的一集敗品。搜影評時看到這段特中肯

by 網民 heathcliffe bird
: ＂So... Girl with stripey face needs to sing a song to keep ancient god
: happy... Except its not a god, its a mummy. Except its not a mummy, its a
: vampire. Except its not singing, it's sacrificing. Except its not the
: vampire, its the sun. Except its not a sun, its a parasite. But the doctor
: pours his history into it to fix it. And it dies. or doesnt. But Clara pours
: her leaf into it, to fix it. But is the 'never happened' that wins. And then
: its dead. Or happy. Or something. And she gets her mums ring back, 'cause
: they love her.＂

: I'm such a fan boy for this show, but this weeks storyline was beyond
: terrible... I really hope I missed the point of it and its there for a
: reason... Otherwise my argument about this being one of the greatest things
: on tv just took a severe dent.

反正就是個不分青紅皂白的急轉直下，直到喔耶贏了~~一片代表無窮無盡可能未來與
Clara對媽媽的愛的楓紅樹葉很好很強大~~結尾劇終

DW這種偏Fantasy/SF的劇總有那種劇情點的決勝時刻，能否抓住觀眾的心的'wow moment'
這集沒有......或是說正妹對蘿莉<del>摸頭</del>傾訴對母親的愛、蘿莉唱歌、或者
Doctor抬頭挺胸對恆星狀怪物叫罵(連搬輩分這種招數都用了，這招太常出現，要是再度
成功就沒天理了) 這些場景打不動包括我在內的很多觀眾啊。

這劇該不會沒梗啦，衰退啦，掉芝麻啦，魔法特難道不用負責嗎，Matt每上專訪必誇獎
的編劇大人怎麼寫出這種東西= =

......等等，這集編劇不是魔法特......

是一個叫Neil Cross的紐西蘭人，這集是他的初試啼聲然後下下集又是他QQ別鬧了好不好
XD

- - - -

回顧一下DW第五季之後，其實也不是說有魔法特編劇一定有口皆碑，不是他必然不好看這
種事。

很多我光回想起來就雋永的集數都是魔法特以外的編劇

尼爾蓋曼寫的604 The Doctor's Wife 就不用說了，本季末他將回歸再貢獻一集，我們
拭目以待。

然後第六季嚇死人不償命的 609 Night Terrors 跟 611 The God Complex 也是讓我非常
想回去看......某種程度又不太想回去看的好劇。不過這兩位編劇，Mark Gatiss (驚，
這不是Mycroft，捲福他哥嗎) 跟 Toby Whithouse 都很資深，果然生嫩之別，效果十分
顯著XD


--