KANO 觀後感及其他 - 電影

By Edith
at 2014-03-02T16:08
at 2014-03-02T16:08
Table of Contents
個人觀感, 無關對錯.
KANO 是個好故事,
果子工作室是個用心的製片團隊,
但也許企圖太強所以有些地方我覺得不無爭議.
片子的考據用心和不惜成本值得讚賞,
也因此相對而言,
刻意聯結的嘉南大圳顯得有些生硬.
從一些訪談/花絮看來,
團隊是意欲從棒球聯結到土地,
農校到農業建設似乎是自然的事,
不過我看起來像是嘉農隊和八田與一的"英雄惜英雄",
如果是"土地與人"應該要再草根一點,
安排無名英雄(某個老農之類)的說服力會不會更高一點?
(或許有置入性行銷考量,替烏山頭水庫打廣告?)
其他副線如吳投手和阿靜的故事,
教練的家常都有補充主角/社會背景的功用,
我覺得是必要的,
(焦點不應該放在陽剛/陰柔的互補上)
KANO 的時代野球還是日本人的運動,
嘉農的表現替將來的台灣國球打出風氣.
我覺得 KANO 在這點著墨不夠,
魏導/監製訪問中表示的三族共和,
也因為語言太單一化無法彰顯族群差異,
球員的語言問題已經被吵到爛了,
這裡還是提出四點看法:
1,有人說漢人裡不只有閩南人所以不能通台語,
但1930年嘉義市區主流語言是台語,
客家人和閩南人溝通不是完全得靠日語的,
(這點應由老球員證實,但訪談資料似乎沒有答案?)
2,颱風夜嘉中嘉農的衝突,
電影院內的辯士講的是台語,
觀眾也穿漢人服裝,
那麼學生刻意到台語電影院卻不講台語的可能性是?
3,街頭棒球實況轉播可以不用翻譯?
4,那個撿球員(大概初中年紀)向教練自介時的日語會不會太"溜"了點?
不是說語言問題有多嚴重,
這些點也應該可以合理化,
只是覺得一些眉角如果再多一點處理,
或許時代背景會更生動,
"三族共和"也更有說服力
PS: 1930年還沒有推行國語家庭,
還有這裡純討論劇情安排的"眉角",
無關對錯, 謝謝
然後結尾CG也太出戲了, 看得有點ORZ.
以上粗淺的個人看法,
好話當然也有,
都被別人說得差不多就不贅述了
--
Tags:
電影
All Comments

By Yedda
at 2014-03-04T02:34
at 2014-03-04T02:34

By Victoria
at 2014-03-05T16:07
at 2014-03-05T16:07

By William
at 2014-03-05T20:36
at 2014-03-05T20:36

By Olive
at 2014-03-08T09:28
at 2014-03-08T09:28

By Rachel
at 2014-03-10T18:59
at 2014-03-10T18:59

By Elvira
at 2014-03-13T16:47
at 2014-03-13T16:47

By Rae
at 2014-03-15T06:55
at 2014-03-15T06:55

By Zanna
at 2014-03-16T23:02
at 2014-03-16T23:02

By Oscar
at 2014-03-21T05:09
at 2014-03-21T05:09

By Catherine
at 2014-03-26T02:14
at 2014-03-26T02:14

By Dora
at 2014-03-26T16:16
at 2014-03-26T16:16

By Rachel
at 2014-03-29T14:58
at 2014-03-29T14:58

By Skylar DavisLinda
at 2014-04-01T17:23
at 2014-04-01T17:23

By Freda
at 2014-04-02T00:07
at 2014-04-02T00:07

By Michael
at 2014-04-05T15:06
at 2014-04-05T15:06

By Caitlin
at 2014-04-07T20:58
at 2014-04-07T20:58

By Zora
at 2014-04-09T20:28
at 2014-04-09T20:28

By Kama
at 2014-04-12T16:02
at 2014-04-12T16:02

By Ophelia
at 2014-04-15T14:48
at 2014-04-15T14:48

By Eden
at 2014-04-16T11:26
at 2014-04-16T11:26

By Lauren
at 2014-04-17T17:52
at 2014-04-17T17:52

By Robert
at 2014-04-19T00:33
at 2014-04-19T00:33

By Elizabeth
at 2014-04-19T16:21
at 2014-04-19T16:21

By Hedwig
at 2014-04-23T07:48
at 2014-04-23T07:48

By Gilbert
at 2014-04-24T04:09
at 2014-04-24T04:09

By Connor
at 2014-04-28T07:12
at 2014-04-28T07:12

By Andrew
at 2014-04-29T06:20
at 2014-04-29T06:20

By Hamiltion
at 2014-04-29T13:39
at 2014-04-29T13:39

By Hardy
at 2014-05-04T12:08
at 2014-05-04T12:08

By Skylar DavisLinda
at 2014-05-05T02:43
at 2014-05-05T02:43

By Frederic
at 2014-05-05T11:47
at 2014-05-05T11:47

By Kama
at 2014-05-10T11:20
at 2014-05-10T11:20

By Edward Lewis
at 2014-05-11T03:16
at 2014-05-11T03:16

By Bennie
at 2014-05-15T15:38
at 2014-05-15T15:38

By Edward Lewis
at 2014-05-20T06:13
at 2014-05-20T06:13

By Rosalind
at 2014-05-22T02:26
at 2014-05-22T02:26

By Zora
at 2014-05-25T02:10
at 2014-05-25T02:10

By Carolina Franco
at 2014-05-28T00:18
at 2014-05-28T00:18

By Elizabeth
at 2014-05-31T12:17
at 2014-05-31T12:17

By Freda
at 2014-06-04T20:28
at 2014-06-04T20:28

By Wallis
at 2014-06-06T11:09
at 2014-06-06T11:09

By Olga
at 2014-06-11T08:58
at 2014-06-11T08:58

By Edwina
at 2014-06-15T18:57
at 2014-06-15T18:57

By Frederica
at 2014-06-17T14:11
at 2014-06-17T14:11

By Olga
at 2014-06-19T10:22
at 2014-06-19T10:22

By Hedda
at 2014-06-19T12:00
at 2014-06-19T12:00

By Genevieve
at 2014-06-23T01:09
at 2014-06-23T01:09

By Xanthe
at 2014-06-23T09:16
at 2014-06-23T09:16

By Franklin
at 2014-06-23T17:02
at 2014-06-23T17:02

By Harry
at 2014-06-23T19:14
at 2014-06-23T19:14

By Margaret
at 2014-06-28T03:59
at 2014-06-28T03:59

By Freda
at 2014-06-28T23:42
at 2014-06-28T23:42

By Ophelia
at 2014-07-02T14:34
at 2014-07-02T14:34

By Hardy
at 2014-07-06T04:58
at 2014-07-06T04:58

By Dinah
at 2014-07-10T19:34
at 2014-07-10T19:34

By Freda
at 2014-07-12T04:26
at 2014-07-12T04:26

By Kama
at 2014-07-12T11:15
at 2014-07-12T11:15

By Madame
at 2014-07-12T22:57
at 2014-07-12T22:57

By Susan
at 2014-07-13T12:29
at 2014-07-13T12:29

By Kama
at 2014-07-15T12:46
at 2014-07-15T12:46

By Charlotte
at 2014-07-16T21:45
at 2014-07-16T21:45

By Gary
at 2014-07-21T18:57
at 2014-07-21T18:57

By Connor
at 2014-07-24T22:10
at 2014-07-24T22:10

By Kumar
at 2014-07-28T10:26
at 2014-07-28T10:26

By Blanche
at 2014-07-29T20:07
at 2014-07-29T20:07

By John
at 2014-08-03T11:18
at 2014-08-03T11:18

By Hedwig
at 2014-08-03T12:38
at 2014-08-03T12:38

By Gary
at 2014-08-06T15:07
at 2014-08-06T15:07

By Catherine
at 2014-08-09T09:34
at 2014-08-09T09:34

By Dora
at 2014-08-14T00:10
at 2014-08-14T00:10

By Elvira
at 2014-08-15T20:30
at 2014-08-15T20:30

By Rachel
at 2014-08-17T14:25
at 2014-08-17T14:25

By Lily
at 2014-08-17T16:40
at 2014-08-17T16:40

By Rebecca
at 2014-08-19T04:44
at 2014-08-19T04:44

By Harry
at 2014-08-19T20:35
at 2014-08-19T20:35

By Kumar
at 2014-08-22T08:19
at 2014-08-22T08:19

By George
at 2014-08-27T02:03
at 2014-08-27T02:03

By Lauren
at 2014-08-30T20:08
at 2014-08-30T20:08

By Brianna
at 2014-08-31T06:20
at 2014-08-31T06:20

By Audriana
at 2014-09-01T19:29
at 2014-09-01T19:29

By Catherine
at 2014-09-04T07:24
at 2014-09-04T07:24

By Zenobia
at 2014-09-05T08:45
at 2014-09-05T08:45

By Todd Johnson
at 2014-09-07T20:01
at 2014-09-07T20:01

By Freda
at 2014-09-12T19:42
at 2014-09-12T19:42

By Heather
at 2014-09-14T08:46
at 2014-09-14T08:46

By Ursula
at 2014-09-14T17:44
at 2014-09-14T17:44

By Belly
at 2014-09-19T04:39
at 2014-09-19T04:39

By Valerie
at 2014-09-22T08:24
at 2014-09-22T08:24

By Lauren
at 2014-09-26T02:00
at 2014-09-26T02:00

By Catherine
at 2014-09-29T13:08
at 2014-09-29T13:08

By Irma
at 2014-10-03T23:44
at 2014-10-03T23:44

By Victoria
at 2014-10-07T23:00
at 2014-10-07T23:00

By Rosalind
at 2014-10-10T17:20
at 2014-10-10T17:20

By Mary
at 2014-10-12T23:31
at 2014-10-12T23:31

By Emily
at 2014-10-16T14:27
at 2014-10-16T14:27

By Christine
at 2014-10-16T19:20
at 2014-10-16T19:20

By Olivia
at 2014-10-19T04:47
at 2014-10-19T04:47

By Hedy
at 2014-10-21T03:20
at 2014-10-21T03:20

By Todd Johnson
at 2014-10-25T06:08
at 2014-10-25T06:08

By Iris
at 2014-10-27T18:20
at 2014-10-27T18:20

By Barb Cronin
at 2014-10-29T05:16
at 2014-10-29T05:16

By Carol
at 2014-10-29T12:24
at 2014-10-29T12:24

By Vanessa
at 2014-11-02T09:12
at 2014-11-02T09:12

By Charlie
at 2014-11-02T15:50
at 2014-11-02T15:50

By John
at 2014-11-03T23:49
at 2014-11-03T23:49

By Mia
at 2014-11-04T16:20
at 2014-11-04T16:20

By Frederica
at 2014-11-06T21:43
at 2014-11-06T21:43

By Gary
at 2014-11-11T04:24
at 2014-11-11T04:24

By Hedy
at 2014-11-13T22:13
at 2014-11-13T22:13

By Lily
at 2014-11-17T03:28
at 2014-11-17T03:28

By Valerie
at 2014-11-17T19:56
at 2014-11-17T19:56

By Skylar DavisLinda
at 2014-11-21T12:45
at 2014-11-21T12:45

By Edith
at 2014-11-22T18:53
at 2014-11-22T18:53
Related Posts
《史瑞克5》有望啟動

By Edith
at 2014-03-02T16:02
at 2014-03-02T16:02
我喜歡的KANO三幕

By Kelly
at 2014-03-02T15:59
at 2014-03-02T15:59
今年金馬獎

By Andrew
at 2014-03-02T15:52
at 2014-03-02T15:52
連恩喪妻5年 連拍20部片療傷

By Carol
at 2014-03-02T15:41
at 2014-03-02T15:41
萬惡城市2延到2014年上映

By Oliver
at 2014-03-02T15:13
at 2014-03-02T15:13