KANO觀後感,令人感動的嘉南大圳 - 電影

By Andy
at 2014-03-09T22:13
at 2014-03-09T22:13
Table of Contents
嘉南大圳本身是有用的建設
但是日本人建設嘉南大圳,只是殖民剝削手段的進化
對當時的台灣人,絕對稱不上偉大或幸福
電影卻幫那時的台灣人對嘉南大圳的態度注入情感
實在令人不敢苟同
說嘉南大圳甚至嘉農棒球隊是殖民手段,並非意識形態
只需要幾個史實就一清二楚
先說嘉南大圳
(部份資料來源: 《台灣文學學報》第二十三期
宣傳與抵抗:嘉南大圳事業論述的文本縫隙
以及其引用資料)
1. 種出來的米,不是給台灣人吃的,而是給日本人吃的
2. 矢內原忠雄《帝國主義下の臺灣》:
「嘉南大圳所促進的社會關係上的變化,乃是形成大地
主的土地集中與壟斷,及促使農民喪失土地而無產化。」
3. 農民或地主必須繳納高額水租,甚至有人賣子賣妹。
4. 當時報紙頭條
〈嘉南大圳沒有給水也要徵收水租╱地主們大起抗議╱「咬人」大圳的正體暴露╱請看
當局將如何處置〉 《臺灣新民報》
5. 八田與一在嘉南大圳和烏山頭水庫之前毫無工程經驗,以台灣為工程試驗場
烏山頭水庫建成該年底就因中型地震崩塌360公尺
6. 嘉南大圳的基礎是清代已有的水利設施
7. 美軍轟炸台灣嘉南大圳即遭受大規模損壞
8. 烏山頭水庫因施工問題,1940年左右損壞,日本人因戰爭無餘力修復
是國府接收台灣後撥款修復的
由此可知日本帝國/八田與一/嘉南大圳之功
受到了過度的美化和吹捧,為了商業利益或意識形態作這種宣傳
是否真對得起當年的台灣人?
再說嘉農棒球隊
http://www.chinatimes.com/newspapers/20140225000464-260109
我就直接引用這篇了
天下嘉農這個故事本身是很動人
但是所謂跨越種族,對於被殖民者只是妄想
對於殖民者只是一個統治口號
PS. 原文推文提到十大建設是收割日本建設,只能說荒謬不值一駁
--
但是日本人建設嘉南大圳,只是殖民剝削手段的進化
對當時的台灣人,絕對稱不上偉大或幸福
電影卻幫那時的台灣人對嘉南大圳的態度注入情感
實在令人不敢苟同
說嘉南大圳甚至嘉農棒球隊是殖民手段,並非意識形態
只需要幾個史實就一清二楚
先說嘉南大圳
(部份資料來源: 《台灣文學學報》第二十三期
宣傳與抵抗:嘉南大圳事業論述的文本縫隙
以及其引用資料)
1. 種出來的米,不是給台灣人吃的,而是給日本人吃的
2. 矢內原忠雄《帝國主義下の臺灣》:
「嘉南大圳所促進的社會關係上的變化,乃是形成大地
主的土地集中與壟斷,及促使農民喪失土地而無產化。」
3. 農民或地主必須繳納高額水租,甚至有人賣子賣妹。
4. 當時報紙頭條
〈嘉南大圳沒有給水也要徵收水租╱地主們大起抗議╱「咬人」大圳的正體暴露╱請看
當局將如何處置〉 《臺灣新民報》
5. 八田與一在嘉南大圳和烏山頭水庫之前毫無工程經驗,以台灣為工程試驗場
烏山頭水庫建成該年底就因中型地震崩塌360公尺
6. 嘉南大圳的基礎是清代已有的水利設施
7. 美軍轟炸台灣嘉南大圳即遭受大規模損壞
8. 烏山頭水庫因施工問題,1940年左右損壞,日本人因戰爭無餘力修復
是國府接收台灣後撥款修復的
由此可知日本帝國/八田與一/嘉南大圳之功
受到了過度的美化和吹捧,為了商業利益或意識形態作這種宣傳
是否真對得起當年的台灣人?
再說嘉農棒球隊
http://www.chinatimes.com/newspapers/20140225000464-260109
我就直接引用這篇了
天下嘉農這個故事本身是很動人
但是所謂跨越種族,對於被殖民者只是妄想
對於殖民者只是一個統治口號
PS. 原文推文提到十大建設是收割日本建設,只能說荒謬不值一駁
--
Tags:
電影
All Comments

By Odelette
at 2014-03-14T10:22
at 2014-03-14T10:22

By Blanche
at 2014-03-19T09:01
at 2014-03-19T09:01

By James
at 2014-03-23T06:15
at 2014-03-23T06:15

By Robert
at 2014-03-23T13:38
at 2014-03-23T13:38

By Xanthe
at 2014-03-25T15:28
at 2014-03-25T15:28

By Lydia
at 2014-03-26T21:37
at 2014-03-26T21:37

By Gilbert
at 2014-03-29T06:13
at 2014-03-29T06:13

By Zenobia
at 2014-04-01T21:19
at 2014-04-01T21:19

By Agnes
at 2014-04-04T00:58
at 2014-04-04T00:58

By Hardy
at 2014-04-05T08:57
at 2014-04-05T08:57

By Ophelia
at 2014-04-06T00:43
at 2014-04-06T00:43

By Ursula
at 2014-04-06T22:15
at 2014-04-06T22:15

By Suhail Hany
at 2014-04-08T04:57
at 2014-04-08T04:57

By Jacky
at 2014-04-10T13:06
at 2014-04-10T13:06

By Sierra Rose
at 2014-04-11T21:30
at 2014-04-11T21:30

By Emily
at 2014-04-13T17:27
at 2014-04-13T17:27

By Olive
at 2014-04-16T23:45
at 2014-04-16T23:45

By Una
at 2014-04-18T16:51
at 2014-04-18T16:51

By Madame
at 2014-04-21T21:08
at 2014-04-21T21:08

By Madame
at 2014-04-24T13:32
at 2014-04-24T13:32

By Edward Lewis
at 2014-04-29T05:39
at 2014-04-29T05:39

By Agatha
at 2014-05-04T04:05
at 2014-05-04T04:05

By Jessica
at 2014-05-04T13:51
at 2014-05-04T13:51

By Quintina
at 2014-05-08T04:33
at 2014-05-08T04:33

By Donna
at 2014-05-10T06:54
at 2014-05-10T06:54

By Vanessa
at 2014-05-11T23:38
at 2014-05-11T23:38

By Frederic
at 2014-05-16T09:16
at 2014-05-16T09:16

By Wallis
at 2014-05-18T08:28
at 2014-05-18T08:28

By Blanche
at 2014-05-22T12:33
at 2014-05-22T12:33

By Mason
at 2014-05-24T03:22
at 2014-05-24T03:22

By Carolina Franco
at 2014-05-26T05:12
at 2014-05-26T05:12

By Jacky
at 2014-05-29T20:12
at 2014-05-29T20:12

By Ophelia
at 2014-06-01T21:27
at 2014-06-01T21:27

By Robert
at 2014-06-06T03:34
at 2014-06-06T03:34

By David
at 2014-06-06T05:49
at 2014-06-06T05:49

By Quanna
at 2014-06-08T15:13
at 2014-06-08T15:13

By Edith
at 2014-06-12T18:17
at 2014-06-12T18:17

By James
at 2014-06-15T17:05
at 2014-06-15T17:05

By Charlie
at 2014-06-15T19:31
at 2014-06-15T19:31

By Jack
at 2014-06-16T12:08
at 2014-06-16T12:08

By Faithe
at 2014-06-20T18:33
at 2014-06-20T18:33

By Belly
at 2014-06-22T21:22
at 2014-06-22T21:22

By Doris
at 2014-06-24T03:44
at 2014-06-24T03:44

By Faithe
at 2014-06-24T17:00
at 2014-06-24T17:00

By Charlotte
at 2014-06-25T11:01
at 2014-06-25T11:01

By Damian
at 2014-06-27T00:58
at 2014-06-27T00:58

By Oliver
at 2014-06-28T03:53
at 2014-06-28T03:53

By Yuri
at 2014-06-30T09:35
at 2014-06-30T09:35

By Annie
at 2014-07-01T16:58
at 2014-07-01T16:58

By Andy
at 2014-07-06T06:06
at 2014-07-06T06:06

By Hedwig
at 2014-07-08T14:00
at 2014-07-08T14:00

By Bennie
at 2014-07-11T14:12
at 2014-07-11T14:12

By Catherine
at 2014-07-12T23:16
at 2014-07-12T23:16

By Victoria
at 2014-07-17T02:38
at 2014-07-17T02:38

By Faithe
at 2014-07-19T07:23
at 2014-07-19T07:23

By Damian
at 2014-07-21T11:53
at 2014-07-21T11:53

By Odelette
at 2014-07-24T02:13
at 2014-07-24T02:13

By John
at 2014-07-25T17:16
at 2014-07-25T17:16

By Anonymous
at 2014-07-26T07:11
at 2014-07-26T07:11

By Andy
at 2014-07-29T05:16
at 2014-07-29T05:16

By Hedda
at 2014-07-30T16:54
at 2014-07-30T16:54

By Edith
at 2014-08-04T05:54
at 2014-08-04T05:54

By Gilbert
at 2014-08-09T00:13
at 2014-08-09T00:13

By Callum
at 2014-08-09T13:44
at 2014-08-09T13:44

By Joseph
at 2014-08-10T02:07
at 2014-08-10T02:07

By Necoo
at 2014-08-14T03:25
at 2014-08-14T03:25

By Erin
at 2014-08-16T05:22
at 2014-08-16T05:22

By Ursula
at 2014-08-17T22:20
at 2014-08-17T22:20

By Ursula
at 2014-08-21T20:29
at 2014-08-21T20:29

By Robert
at 2014-08-23T04:01
at 2014-08-23T04:01

By Damian
at 2014-08-26T23:12
at 2014-08-26T23:12

By Edith
at 2014-08-27T18:51
at 2014-08-27T18:51

By Damian
at 2014-08-28T21:13
at 2014-08-28T21:13

By David
at 2014-08-29T09:51
at 2014-08-29T09:51

By Adele
at 2014-08-31T19:03
at 2014-08-31T19:03

By Agnes
at 2014-09-01T23:10
at 2014-09-01T23:10

By Victoria
at 2014-09-04T03:25
at 2014-09-04T03:25

By Eden
at 2014-09-08T14:06
at 2014-09-08T14:06

By Hardy
at 2014-09-11T01:03
at 2014-09-11T01:03

By Carolina Franco
at 2014-09-15T17:53
at 2014-09-15T17:53

By Delia
at 2014-09-19T09:35
at 2014-09-19T09:35

By Lucy
at 2014-09-19T13:01
at 2014-09-19T13:01

By Todd Johnson
at 2014-09-20T06:55
at 2014-09-20T06:55

By Robert
at 2014-09-23T22:31
at 2014-09-23T22:31

By Vanessa
at 2014-09-28T05:40
at 2014-09-28T05:40

By Carol
at 2014-09-30T02:18
at 2014-09-30T02:18

By Poppy
at 2014-09-30T14:15
at 2014-09-30T14:15

By William
at 2014-10-04T04:03
at 2014-10-04T04:03

By Noah
at 2014-10-08T11:20
at 2014-10-08T11:20

By Frederica
at 2014-10-13T05:34
at 2014-10-13T05:34

By Madame
at 2014-10-18T03:04
at 2014-10-18T03:04

By Zora
at 2014-10-21T18:54
at 2014-10-21T18:54

By Ivy
at 2014-10-22T04:28
at 2014-10-22T04:28

By Barb Cronin
at 2014-10-24T13:26
at 2014-10-24T13:26

By Gilbert
at 2014-10-29T09:56
at 2014-10-29T09:56

By Edith
at 2014-10-30T07:16
at 2014-10-30T07:16

By Jessica
at 2014-11-01T12:44
at 2014-11-01T12:44

By Steve
at 2014-11-02T09:21
at 2014-11-02T09:21

By Jessica
at 2014-11-03T02:48
at 2014-11-03T02:48

By Lucy
at 2014-11-05T20:20
at 2014-11-05T20:20

By Jacob
at 2014-11-08T07:43
at 2014-11-08T07:43

By Necoo
at 2014-11-09T23:49
at 2014-11-09T23:49

By Freda
at 2014-11-10T04:45
at 2014-11-10T04:45

By Ivy
at 2014-11-11T21:06
at 2014-11-11T21:06

By Ursula
at 2014-11-15T16:00
at 2014-11-15T16:00

By Anthony
at 2014-11-19T22:13
at 2014-11-19T22:13

By Isla
at 2014-11-21T01:57
at 2014-11-21T01:57

By Carol
at 2014-11-22T11:22
at 2014-11-22T11:22

By Edward Lewis
at 2014-11-24T07:43
at 2014-11-24T07:43

By Cara
at 2014-11-26T19:09
at 2014-11-26T19:09

By Gary
at 2014-11-27T13:55
at 2014-11-27T13:55

By Caroline
at 2014-11-27T21:25
at 2014-11-27T21:25

By Cara
at 2014-12-01T11:54
at 2014-12-01T11:54

By Andy
at 2014-12-04T10:53
at 2014-12-04T10:53

By Lily
at 2014-12-09T10:52
at 2014-12-09T10:52

By Jacky
at 2014-12-13T00:56
at 2014-12-13T00:56

By Lauren
at 2014-12-14T17:21
at 2014-12-14T17:21

By Ina
at 2014-12-19T07:03
at 2014-12-19T07:03

By Catherine
at 2014-12-23T17:43
at 2014-12-23T17:43

By Adele
at 2014-12-26T08:28
at 2014-12-26T08:28

By Brianna
at 2014-12-30T06:48
at 2014-12-30T06:48

By Necoo
at 2015-01-03T09:06
at 2015-01-03T09:06

By Joe
at 2015-01-08T00:14
at 2015-01-08T00:14

By Anthony
at 2015-01-09T03:51
at 2015-01-09T03:51

By Daph Bay
at 2015-01-10T12:29
at 2015-01-10T12:29

By Quintina
at 2015-01-11T15:06
at 2015-01-11T15:06

By Tristan Cohan
at 2015-01-14T20:21
at 2015-01-14T20:21

By Steve
at 2015-01-19T02:19
at 2015-01-19T02:19

By Yedda
at 2015-01-21T02:56
at 2015-01-21T02:56

By Hardy
at 2015-01-22T09:23
at 2015-01-22T09:23

By David
at 2015-01-23T09:06
at 2015-01-23T09:06

By Harry
at 2015-01-25T12:41
at 2015-01-25T12:41

By Kyle
at 2015-01-30T11:25
at 2015-01-30T11:25

By Adele
at 2015-02-01T14:41
at 2015-02-01T14:41

By Adele
at 2015-02-06T05:36
at 2015-02-06T05:36

By Dorothy
at 2015-02-10T14:06
at 2015-02-10T14:06

By Joseph
at 2015-02-14T19:53
at 2015-02-14T19:53

By Caitlin
at 2015-02-19T01:45
at 2015-02-19T01:45

By Bethany
at 2015-02-23T04:18
at 2015-02-23T04:18

By Ethan
at 2015-02-28T02:48
at 2015-02-28T02:48

By Ethan
at 2015-03-03T05:39
at 2015-03-03T05:39

By Zenobia
at 2015-03-04T16:20
at 2015-03-04T16:20

By Carolina Franco
at 2015-03-05T19:22
at 2015-03-05T19:22

By Leila
at 2015-03-07T01:45
at 2015-03-07T01:45

By Ivy
at 2015-03-10T03:16
at 2015-03-10T03:16

By Puput
at 2015-03-13T05:04
at 2015-03-13T05:04

By Rosalind
at 2015-03-14T07:27
at 2015-03-14T07:27

By Lucy
at 2015-03-16T01:54
at 2015-03-16T01:54

By Jack
at 2015-03-20T18:52
at 2015-03-20T18:52

By Belly
at 2015-03-25T01:39
at 2015-03-25T01:39

By Carol
at 2015-03-29T05:54
at 2015-03-29T05:54

By Isabella
at 2015-03-30T06:26
at 2015-03-30T06:26

By Kelly
at 2015-04-02T05:42
at 2015-04-02T05:42

By Olive
at 2015-04-04T11:56
at 2015-04-04T11:56

By Joe
at 2015-04-05T21:19
at 2015-04-05T21:19

By Mason
at 2015-04-08T11:09
at 2015-04-08T11:09

By Leila
at 2015-04-11T00:24
at 2015-04-11T00:24

By Carol
at 2015-04-16T00:18
at 2015-04-16T00:18

By Brianna
at 2015-04-20T21:42
at 2015-04-20T21:42

By Ethan
at 2015-04-24T07:01
at 2015-04-24T07:01

By Erin
at 2015-04-25T04:03
at 2015-04-25T04:03

By Dinah
at 2015-04-28T12:40
at 2015-04-28T12:40

By Audriana
at 2015-05-02T03:13
at 2015-05-02T03:13

By Quanna
at 2015-05-04T17:06
at 2015-05-04T17:06

By Candice
at 2015-05-07T18:59
at 2015-05-07T18:59

By Lauren
at 2015-05-08T20:11
at 2015-05-08T20:11

By Hardy
at 2015-05-10T15:25
at 2015-05-10T15:25

By Franklin
at 2015-05-11T12:41
at 2015-05-11T12:41

By Franklin
at 2015-05-14T14:22
at 2015-05-14T14:22

By Mason
at 2015-05-15T00:50
at 2015-05-15T00:50

By Christine
at 2015-05-19T14:11
at 2015-05-19T14:11

By Bennie
at 2015-05-22T19:18
at 2015-05-22T19:18

By Xanthe
at 2015-05-26T07:31
at 2015-05-26T07:31

By Enid
at 2015-05-30T05:09
at 2015-05-30T05:09

By Suhail Hany
at 2015-05-31T20:12
at 2015-05-31T20:12

By Elvira
at 2015-06-02T15:44
at 2015-06-02T15:44

By Doris
at 2015-06-07T03:47
at 2015-06-07T03:47

By Damian
at 2015-06-10T00:57
at 2015-06-10T00:57

By Dora
at 2015-06-13T05:30
at 2015-06-13T05:30

By Hazel
at 2015-06-13T09:20
at 2015-06-13T09:20

By Victoria
at 2015-06-14T12:28
at 2015-06-14T12:28

By Zanna
at 2015-06-16T13:55
at 2015-06-16T13:55

By Hedda
at 2015-06-17T22:29
at 2015-06-17T22:29

By Olga
at 2015-06-19T21:10
at 2015-06-19T21:10

By Linda
at 2015-06-20T12:00
at 2015-06-20T12:00

By Suhail Hany
at 2015-06-21T19:41
at 2015-06-21T19:41

By Barb Cronin
at 2015-06-22T12:03
at 2015-06-22T12:03

By Caitlin
at 2015-06-23T08:42
at 2015-06-23T08:42

By Hedda
at 2015-06-24T03:39
at 2015-06-24T03:39

By Emma
at 2015-06-28T01:31
at 2015-06-28T01:31

By Brianna
at 2015-07-01T17:15
at 2015-07-01T17:15

By Wallis
at 2015-07-02T02:15
at 2015-07-02T02:15

By Ula
at 2015-07-03T08:58
at 2015-07-03T08:58

By Gilbert
at 2015-07-07T20:00
at 2015-07-07T20:00

By Valerie
at 2015-07-08T18:00
at 2015-07-08T18:00

By Elizabeth
at 2015-07-12T18:14
at 2015-07-12T18:14

By Hazel
at 2015-07-17T10:51
at 2015-07-17T10:51

By Connor
at 2015-07-20T01:49
at 2015-07-20T01:49

By Hardy
at 2015-07-23T01:44
at 2015-07-23T01:44

By Caroline
at 2015-07-24T02:43
at 2015-07-24T02:43

By Una
at 2015-07-27T12:35
at 2015-07-27T12:35

By Hardy
at 2015-07-28T11:34
at 2015-07-28T11:34

By Hardy
at 2015-07-28T14:20
at 2015-07-28T14:20

By Hardy
at 2015-07-28T22:37
at 2015-07-28T22:37

By Connor
at 2015-08-01T18:43
at 2015-08-01T18:43

By Puput
at 2015-08-03T11:23
at 2015-08-03T11:23

By Rae
at 2015-08-05T18:21
at 2015-08-05T18:21

By Megan
at 2015-08-07T06:41
at 2015-08-07T06:41

By Edwina
at 2015-08-11T14:40
at 2015-08-11T14:40

By Quintina
at 2015-08-13T06:29
at 2015-08-13T06:29

By Daniel
at 2015-08-15T06:03
at 2015-08-15T06:03

By Christine
at 2015-08-18T21:46
at 2015-08-18T21:46

By Linda
at 2015-08-19T06:24
at 2015-08-19T06:24

By Steve
at 2015-08-23T01:15
at 2015-08-23T01:15

By Charlie
at 2015-08-24T18:16
at 2015-08-24T18:16

By Quintina
at 2015-08-26T07:42
at 2015-08-26T07:42

By Emma
at 2015-08-30T05:47
at 2015-08-30T05:47
Related Posts
危險尤物伊娃葛林 「300壯士」再露點

By Eartha
at 2014-03-09T22:11
at 2014-03-09T22:11
KANO-父母親都說讚

By Daph Bay
at 2014-03-09T22:10
at 2014-03-09T22:10
藥命俱樂部

By Ingrid
at 2014-03-09T22:07
at 2014-03-09T22:07
本屆日本奧斯卡 「宅男的戀愛字典」大贏

By Tristan Cohan
at 2014-03-09T22:07
at 2014-03-09T22:07
專訪柏林影帝廖凡:像一把藏在鞘中的寶劍

By Zenobia
at 2014-03-09T22:01
at 2014-03-09T22:01