《拜託小姐》─反推薦 - 韓劇
By Dinah
at 2009-11-08T22:45
at 2009-11-08T22:45
Table of Contents
憋了很久...因為這部蠻多人愛的...所以等熱潮過後再來踩...(大笑)
這部也是很忍耐的食完...(所以不吐不行...╮(﹋﹏﹌)╭)
這劇的問題之前很多人提過了,角色性格前後不一致,人物之間的情感轉移跳太快,
前4集的跳tone已經嚴重影響我看劇的投入度了...( ̄▽ ̄#...可以不要看啊...)
先吐角色吧...
這劇只有女二(文彩元)的角色是成功的,女一男一男二全都不合格,
丁一宇的年紀外型還不到可以演律師這類型的專業角色,
當然演員並非只能演符合自己年紀的人物,
但是就這劇來看,丁一宇沒有把律師這角色駕馭好,
跟'頭球'的高雅拉一樣不適合體育經紀人的角色,同樣的道理,角色錯置。
男一管家的角色塑造非常失敗,
尹尚賢的演技沒有問題,事實上他的詮釋已盡力挽救'徐東燦'這角色了,
做為富豪家又是小姐的首席貼身管家,'徐東燦'的能力跟形象很空洞,
Butler service,我真的看不到也感覺不到,
基本上讓這麼一個未經過專業訓練的人進宅邸當管家已經超級扯了...
爺爺的理由連我小學的姪女都無法說服...( ̄▽ ̄#...不用這麼認真吧...)
Butler service的基本工作,劇中完全沒有演出來,
原本認為日劇'我的帥管家'劇情很蠢,但看了'小姐'的'徐東燦'...
突然覺得'我的帥管家'也不是完全不值得看的劇...
怎麼說才好?
'小姐'的'徐東燦'就只是掛著'執事'的名牌,跟丁一宇掛著'律師'的名牌一樣,
兩個本應是各有專業的角色卻一點都不專業...( ̄▽ ̄#...不會去看職業劇喔?)
女一角色完全不知所云,
一開始設定跟初戀情人的分手影響她的性格至深,感情也因此封閉了好幾年,
可是才見了男二律師一面就整個失魂落魄,
拜託~~~之前的暗自神傷與癡情是耍觀眾喔?也不是情竇初開的少女,
在男二面前卻小女生樣...先前相親時做為富家小姐的矜持在哪裡啊?
能夠讓女一完全,真的是完全把初戀給踹飛,後來再也不見她想到初戀了...
這麼強大的男二(雖然不知道女一被電倒的原因),最後還是不敵男一管家...
...
說實話,前面我看不懂女一為什麼對男二心動,後面她發現管家才是真愛,
斷然拋開男二之後跟管家兩人天雷勾動地火...大家覺得很閃很粉紅的戲份包括滾床單...
我看完只想說編劇去死...( ︶︿︶)_╭∩╮
女一跟男二的感情線是硬湊在一起,既然湊在一起了基本的交往卻沒著墨...
兩人連bobo都沒有過,男二就求婚?又不是朝鮮時代...切
男女主角感情發酵的關鍵點找不到,也沒經歷過什麼重大的讓兩人感情深刻的事件,
兩人感情爆發的讓我莫名其妙...
( ̄▽ ̄#...這麼莫名其妙的劇還堅持看完真是委屈你啦...)
這編劇的作品果然不合我口味...跟'頭球'的編劇一起列入黑名單!
推薦指數:★★
因為女二的角色及跟男二之間的對手戲還蠻自然有趣的...
男一尹尚賢真的不錯,但尹恩惠的詮釋...個人覺得蠻失敗的...(角色本身也很失敗)
--
這部也是很忍耐的食完...(所以不吐不行...╮(﹋﹏﹌)╭)
這劇的問題之前很多人提過了,角色性格前後不一致,人物之間的情感轉移跳太快,
前4集的跳tone已經嚴重影響我看劇的投入度了...( ̄▽ ̄#...可以不要看啊...)
先吐角色吧...
這劇只有女二(文彩元)的角色是成功的,女一男一男二全都不合格,
丁一宇的年紀外型還不到可以演律師這類型的專業角色,
當然演員並非只能演符合自己年紀的人物,
但是就這劇來看,丁一宇沒有把律師這角色駕馭好,
跟'頭球'的高雅拉一樣不適合體育經紀人的角色,同樣的道理,角色錯置。
男一管家的角色塑造非常失敗,
尹尚賢的演技沒有問題,事實上他的詮釋已盡力挽救'徐東燦'這角色了,
做為富豪家又是小姐的首席貼身管家,'徐東燦'的能力跟形象很空洞,
Butler service,我真的看不到也感覺不到,
基本上讓這麼一個未經過專業訓練的人進宅邸當管家已經超級扯了...
爺爺的理由連我小學的姪女都無法說服...( ̄▽ ̄#...不用這麼認真吧...)
Butler service的基本工作,劇中完全沒有演出來,
原本認為日劇'我的帥管家'劇情很蠢,但看了'小姐'的'徐東燦'...
突然覺得'我的帥管家'也不是完全不值得看的劇...
怎麼說才好?
'小姐'的'徐東燦'就只是掛著'執事'的名牌,跟丁一宇掛著'律師'的名牌一樣,
兩個本應是各有專業的角色卻一點都不專業...( ̄▽ ̄#...不會去看職業劇喔?)
女一角色完全不知所云,
一開始設定跟初戀情人的分手影響她的性格至深,感情也因此封閉了好幾年,
可是才見了男二律師一面就整個失魂落魄,
拜託~~~之前的暗自神傷與癡情是耍觀眾喔?也不是情竇初開的少女,
在男二面前卻小女生樣...先前相親時做為富家小姐的矜持在哪裡啊?
能夠讓女一完全,真的是完全把初戀給踹飛,後來再也不見她想到初戀了...
這麼強大的男二(雖然不知道女一被電倒的原因),最後還是不敵男一管家...
...
說實話,前面我看不懂女一為什麼對男二心動,後面她發現管家才是真愛,
斷然拋開男二之後跟管家兩人天雷勾動地火...大家覺得很閃很粉紅的戲份包括滾床單...
我看完只想說編劇去死...( ︶︿︶)_╭∩╮
女一跟男二的感情線是硬湊在一起,既然湊在一起了基本的交往卻沒著墨...
兩人連bobo都沒有過,男二就求婚?又不是朝鮮時代...切
男女主角感情發酵的關鍵點找不到,也沒經歷過什麼重大的讓兩人感情深刻的事件,
兩人感情爆發的讓我莫名其妙...
( ̄▽ ̄#...這麼莫名其妙的劇還堅持看完真是委屈你啦...)
這編劇的作品果然不合我口味...跟'頭球'的編劇一起列入黑名單!
推薦指數:★★
因為女二的角色及跟男二之間的對手戲還蠻自然有趣的...
男一尹尚賢真的不錯,但尹恩惠的詮釋...個人覺得蠻失敗的...(角色本身也很失敗)
--
Tags:
韓劇
All Comments
By William
at 2009-11-12T17:53
at 2009-11-12T17:53
By Joe
at 2009-11-16T08:39
at 2009-11-16T08:39
By Audriana
at 2009-11-20T23:08
at 2009-11-20T23:08
By Daph Bay
at 2009-11-23T05:12
at 2009-11-23T05:12
By Ina
at 2009-11-25T18:45
at 2009-11-25T18:45
By Brianna
at 2009-11-27T22:14
at 2009-11-27T22:14
By Regina
at 2009-12-01T09:25
at 2009-12-01T09:25
By Anonymous
at 2009-12-06T08:42
at 2009-12-06T08:42
By Annie
at 2009-12-08T20:50
at 2009-12-08T20:50
By Anonymous
at 2009-12-10T01:40
at 2009-12-10T01:40
By Mary
at 2009-12-10T19:46
at 2009-12-10T19:46
By Odelette
at 2009-12-14T19:44
at 2009-12-14T19:44
By Blanche
at 2009-12-17T20:44
at 2009-12-17T20:44
By Joe
at 2009-12-18T23:36
at 2009-12-18T23:36
By Quintina
at 2009-12-23T20:51
at 2009-12-23T20:51
By Daph Bay
at 2009-12-26T01:51
at 2009-12-26T01:51
By Brianna
at 2009-12-27T18:44
at 2009-12-27T18:44
By Olga
at 2009-12-31T08:11
at 2009-12-31T08:11
By Edward Lewis
at 2010-01-01T06:49
at 2010-01-01T06:49
By Erin
at 2010-01-01T19:39
at 2010-01-01T19:39
By Odelette
at 2010-01-05T01:47
at 2010-01-05T01:47
By Zenobia
at 2010-01-05T22:04
at 2010-01-05T22:04
By Charlotte
at 2010-01-10T05:16
at 2010-01-10T05:16
By Ursula
at 2010-01-14T13:02
at 2010-01-14T13:02
By Iris
at 2010-01-14T19:16
at 2010-01-14T19:16
By Emily
at 2010-01-18T05:28
at 2010-01-18T05:28
By Jake
at 2010-01-18T14:22
at 2010-01-18T14:22
By Ethan
at 2010-01-19T01:38
at 2010-01-19T01:38
By Megan
at 2010-01-23T20:44
at 2010-01-23T20:44
By Charlotte
at 2010-01-27T12:52
at 2010-01-27T12:52
By Kristin
at 2010-01-31T16:08
at 2010-01-31T16:08
By Rachel
at 2010-02-02T21:35
at 2010-02-02T21:35
By Hedwig
at 2010-02-06T20:11
at 2010-02-06T20:11
By Poppy
at 2010-02-11T01:52
at 2010-02-11T01:52
By Hamiltion
at 2010-02-14T23:39
at 2010-02-14T23:39
By Eden
at 2010-02-16T15:20
at 2010-02-16T15:20
By Blanche
at 2010-02-18T00:50
at 2010-02-18T00:50
By Elvira
at 2010-02-22T16:41
at 2010-02-22T16:41
By Tristan Cohan
at 2010-02-24T09:55
at 2010-02-24T09:55
By Madame
at 2010-02-27T04:19
at 2010-02-27T04:19
By Yedda
at 2010-03-01T02:09
at 2010-03-01T02:09
By Steve
at 2010-03-02T11:26
at 2010-03-02T11:26
By Zanna
at 2010-03-02T15:27
at 2010-03-02T15:27
By Ida
at 2010-03-06T00:05
at 2010-03-06T00:05
By Aaliyah
at 2010-03-06T06:47
at 2010-03-06T06:47
By Lydia
at 2010-03-09T12:59
at 2010-03-09T12:59
By Frederica
at 2010-03-09T16:16
at 2010-03-09T16:16
By Linda
at 2010-03-11T15:27
at 2010-03-11T15:27
By Gary
at 2010-03-15T04:32
at 2010-03-15T04:32
By Callum
at 2010-03-16T08:02
at 2010-03-16T08:02
By Kristin
at 2010-03-20T23:58
at 2010-03-20T23:58
By Damian
at 2010-03-23T22:57
at 2010-03-23T22:57
By Olive
at 2010-03-26T03:55
at 2010-03-26T03:55
By Damian
at 2010-03-28T12:37
at 2010-03-28T12:37
By Necoo
at 2010-03-30T14:39
at 2010-03-30T14:39
By Lily
at 2010-04-03T04:56
at 2010-04-03T04:56
By Candice
at 2010-04-05T23:36
at 2010-04-05T23:36
By Rachel
at 2010-04-09T18:26
at 2010-04-09T18:26
By Bennie
at 2010-04-13T10:47
at 2010-04-13T10:47
By Adele
at 2010-04-15T19:40
at 2010-04-15T19:40
By Bennie
at 2010-04-17T08:54
at 2010-04-17T08:54
By Faithe
at 2010-04-20T17:20
at 2010-04-20T17:20
By Catherine
at 2010-04-21T00:49
at 2010-04-21T00:49
By Jake
at 2010-04-24T16:07
at 2010-04-24T16:07
By Daniel
at 2010-04-29T10:54
at 2010-04-29T10:54
By Ivy
at 2010-04-30T02:42
at 2010-04-30T02:42
By Mia
at 2010-05-05T01:49
at 2010-05-05T01:49
By Oscar
at 2010-05-09T05:55
at 2010-05-09T05:55
By Wallis
at 2010-05-10T14:16
at 2010-05-10T14:16
By Oscar
at 2010-05-14T16:10
at 2010-05-14T16:10
By Rachel
at 2010-05-18T16:46
at 2010-05-18T16:46
By Enid
at 2010-05-20T23:00
at 2010-05-20T23:00
By Sarah
at 2010-05-21T03:36
at 2010-05-21T03:36
By Kristin
at 2010-05-22T09:44
at 2010-05-22T09:44
By Thomas
at 2010-05-23T07:31
at 2010-05-23T07:31
By Kristin
at 2010-05-28T06:06
at 2010-05-28T06:06
By Megan
at 2010-06-01T02:41
at 2010-06-01T02:41
By Dorothy
at 2010-06-05T03:39
at 2010-06-05T03:39
By Quanna
at 2010-06-06T19:07
at 2010-06-06T19:07
By Lauren
at 2010-06-10T01:14
at 2010-06-10T01:14
By Andy
at 2010-06-12T01:22
at 2010-06-12T01:22
By Puput
at 2010-06-13T09:59
at 2010-06-13T09:59
By Ingrid
at 2010-06-18T07:42
at 2010-06-18T07:42
By Eden
at 2010-06-22T05:32
at 2010-06-22T05:32
By Rachel
at 2010-06-26T19:47
at 2010-06-26T19:47
By Hedy
at 2010-06-27T10:09
at 2010-06-27T10:09
By Blanche
at 2010-07-01T04:44
at 2010-07-01T04:44
By Skylar Davis
at 2010-07-04T23:44
at 2010-07-04T23:44
By Eartha
at 2010-07-08T06:52
at 2010-07-08T06:52
By Emily
at 2010-07-10T17:54
at 2010-07-10T17:54
By Bethany
at 2010-07-13T21:19
at 2010-07-13T21:19
By Hedy
at 2010-07-15T03:50
at 2010-07-15T03:50
By Kelly
at 2010-07-19T14:49
at 2010-07-19T14:49
By Regina
at 2010-07-22T05:32
at 2010-07-22T05:32
By James
at 2010-07-24T16:55
at 2010-07-24T16:55
Related Posts
創造情緣 ep9~10 <雷> 進度好慢 >"<
By Kama
at 2009-11-08T20:44
at 2009-11-08T20:44
《向大地頭球》─反推薦
By Olive
at 2009-11-08T20:27
at 2009-11-08T20:27
美男的重度患者 EP1~EP4
By Genevieve
at 2009-11-08T04:48
at 2009-11-08T04:48
Iris ep7-8 有雷
By Megan
at 2009-11-08T02:34
at 2009-11-08T02:34
你笑了ep13 <雷>..
By Selena
at 2009-11-07T23:40
at 2009-11-07T23:40