《色,戒》遭基督教團體杯葛 轟李安漢奸 - 李安

By Mason
at 2007-10-07T14:00
at 2007-10-07T14:00
Table of Contents
※ [本文轉錄自 movie 看板]
作者: decentwork (分享打工心情) 看板: movie
標題: [奇聞]《色,戒》遭基督教團體杯葛 轟李安「漢奸」
時間: Sat Oct 6 17:40:09 2007
《色,戒》遭杯葛 轟李安「漢奸」
10月06日 星期六 05:30AM
(星島日報報道)華人導演李安執導的電影《色,戒》,獲萬千影迷擊節讚賞,電影更揚威
威尼斯影展,勇奪最佳影片金獅獎。但基督教組織傳統家庭促進會則指該電影故意賣弄色
情,引人犯罪,呼籲全球華人杯葛《色,戒》。本港有教會團體稱,會研究是否回應有關
呼籲。
記者:陶法德
以加州為基地的傳統家庭促進會,關注金獅獎得獎電影《色,戒》傳播不良意識,呼籲全
球華人採取杯葛行動。該電影的導演李安及男主角梁朝偉 ,因身在外地,暫時未能就
此作出回應。此外,記者曾致電向《色,戒》的香港發行商安樂電影公司,惟對方亦未有
回覆。
《色》裸露港列三級
《色,戒》改編自著名作家張愛玲的同名短篇小說,故事背景是二次大戰期間被日本佔領
的上海,內容描述一名年輕大學生王佳芝(湯唯飾演),自願獻身,以美人計密謀暗殺汪
精衛政府裏一名特務頭目易先生(梁朝偉飾演)。
由於片中男女主角有不少大膽情慾演出及裸露鏡頭,故《色,戒》於八月底在威尼斯電影
節上取得「最佳影片金獅獎」後,一直被傳媒熱烈報道,而在港上映期間被列為三級片類
別,只准十八歲以上人士入場觀看。
傳統家庭促進會總幹事譚克成博士認為,電影渲染男女之間的性關係,是引誘青少年幹不
道德事情。他指出,電影的歷史背景是第二次世界大戰日本侵華時期,當時不少中國婦女
在不願意情形下,被日本軍人公然性侵犯,惟《色,戒》卻描述一名女性心甘情願出賣肉
體,色誘男人以求達到目的,與當時發生的「慰安婦 」事件成了諷刺性強烈對比,有
辱女性尊嚴。
指有辱女性尊嚴
譚博士更斥責李安是「文化漢奸」:「要中國男女演員在大銀幕上脫光衣服,色誘洋人,
為求一獎……令華人蒙羞!」
香港華人基督教聯會幹事陳先生表示,會將事件向該會主席轉述,若獲主席同意,會將議
題交予董事會研究,再決定是否參與杯葛行動。
明光社總幹事蔡志森表示,自己並未觀看《色,戒》,但該片在港已被列為三級片,有情
慾鏡頭不足為奇:「觀眾可以自己決定是否觀看!」他亦不願評論有關杯葛事件。
導演張同祖則不贊同譚克成言論:「情慾是人的一部分,看不出電影在刻意賣弄!」他希
望大家尊重創作自由,不要過分干涉,「不過,有人呼籲杯葛,等於幫電影做宣傳!」
香港電影評論學會會長岭朗天認為:「青少年的情慾其實超過電影好多倍,反而片中的性
是壓抑,痛苦,完全無挑逗成分,只會令人不想有情慾!」
他表示,宗教團體可呼籲他人杯葛影片,但有理性的人士,應該自行決定。他又補充,電
影無侮辱神,不明宗教團體呼籲杯葛的理由。
--
作者: decentwork (分享打工心情) 看板: movie
標題: [奇聞]《色,戒》遭基督教團體杯葛 轟李安「漢奸」
時間: Sat Oct 6 17:40:09 2007
《色,戒》遭杯葛 轟李安「漢奸」
10月06日 星期六 05:30AM
(星島日報報道)華人導演李安執導的電影《色,戒》,獲萬千影迷擊節讚賞,電影更揚威
威尼斯影展,勇奪最佳影片金獅獎。但基督教組織傳統家庭促進會則指該電影故意賣弄色
情,引人犯罪,呼籲全球華人杯葛《色,戒》。本港有教會團體稱,會研究是否回應有關
呼籲。
記者:陶法德
以加州為基地的傳統家庭促進會,關注金獅獎得獎電影《色,戒》傳播不良意識,呼籲全
球華人採取杯葛行動。該電影的導演李安及男主角梁朝偉 ,因身在外地,暫時未能就
此作出回應。此外,記者曾致電向《色,戒》的香港發行商安樂電影公司,惟對方亦未有
回覆。
《色》裸露港列三級
《色,戒》改編自著名作家張愛玲的同名短篇小說,故事背景是二次大戰期間被日本佔領
的上海,內容描述一名年輕大學生王佳芝(湯唯飾演),自願獻身,以美人計密謀暗殺汪
精衛政府裏一名特務頭目易先生(梁朝偉飾演)。
由於片中男女主角有不少大膽情慾演出及裸露鏡頭,故《色,戒》於八月底在威尼斯電影
節上取得「最佳影片金獅獎」後,一直被傳媒熱烈報道,而在港上映期間被列為三級片類
別,只准十八歲以上人士入場觀看。
傳統家庭促進會總幹事譚克成博士認為,電影渲染男女之間的性關係,是引誘青少年幹不
道德事情。他指出,電影的歷史背景是第二次世界大戰日本侵華時期,當時不少中國婦女
在不願意情形下,被日本軍人公然性侵犯,惟《色,戒》卻描述一名女性心甘情願出賣肉
體,色誘男人以求達到目的,與當時發生的「慰安婦 」事件成了諷刺性強烈對比,有
辱女性尊嚴。
指有辱女性尊嚴
譚博士更斥責李安是「文化漢奸」:「要中國男女演員在大銀幕上脫光衣服,色誘洋人,
為求一獎……令華人蒙羞!」
香港華人基督教聯會幹事陳先生表示,會將事件向該會主席轉述,若獲主席同意,會將議
題交予董事會研究,再決定是否參與杯葛行動。
明光社總幹事蔡志森表示,自己並未觀看《色,戒》,但該片在港已被列為三級片,有情
慾鏡頭不足為奇:「觀眾可以自己決定是否觀看!」他亦不願評論有關杯葛事件。
導演張同祖則不贊同譚克成言論:「情慾是人的一部分,看不出電影在刻意賣弄!」他希
望大家尊重創作自由,不要過分干涉,「不過,有人呼籲杯葛,等於幫電影做宣傳!」
香港電影評論學會會長岭朗天認為:「青少年的情慾其實超過電影好多倍,反而片中的性
是壓抑,痛苦,完全無挑逗成分,只會令人不想有情慾!」
他表示,宗教團體可呼籲他人杯葛影片,但有理性的人士,應該自行決定。他又補充,電
影無侮辱神,不明宗教團體呼籲杯葛的理由。
--
Tags:
李安
All Comments

By Ophelia
at 2007-10-09T22:18
at 2007-10-09T22:18

By Dinah
at 2007-10-12T04:26
at 2007-10-12T04:26

By Linda
at 2007-10-15T19:31
at 2007-10-15T19:31

By Olga
at 2007-10-15T20:41
at 2007-10-15T20:41

By Olivia
at 2007-10-19T02:54
at 2007-10-19T02:54

By Leila
at 2007-10-23T13:18
at 2007-10-23T13:18

By Victoria
at 2007-10-27T18:09
at 2007-10-27T18:09

By Elma
at 2007-10-31T05:40
at 2007-10-31T05:40

By Yuri
at 2007-11-02T10:58
at 2007-11-02T10:58

By Regina
at 2007-11-06T18:50
at 2007-11-06T18:50

By Sierra Rose
at 2007-11-09T01:16
at 2007-11-09T01:16

By David
at 2007-11-10T11:33
at 2007-11-10T11:33

By Kristin
at 2007-11-13T05:04
at 2007-11-13T05:04

By Gilbert
at 2007-11-16T02:08
at 2007-11-16T02:08

By Gilbert
at 2007-11-20T14:38
at 2007-11-20T14:38

By Brianna
at 2007-11-23T18:05
at 2007-11-23T18:05

By Wallis
at 2007-11-25T11:39
at 2007-11-25T11:39

By Megan
at 2007-11-30T00:44
at 2007-11-30T00:44

By Ingrid
at 2007-12-03T14:52
at 2007-12-03T14:52

By Puput
at 2007-12-06T20:50
at 2007-12-06T20:50

By Sandy
at 2007-12-11T08:14
at 2007-12-11T08:14

By Agatha
at 2007-12-11T23:40
at 2007-12-11T23:40

By Puput
at 2007-12-16T18:28
at 2007-12-16T18:28

By Christine
at 2007-12-19T08:03
at 2007-12-19T08:03

By Ethan
at 2007-12-20T01:03
at 2007-12-20T01:03

By Frederica
at 2007-12-24T23:11
at 2007-12-24T23:11

By William
at 2007-12-29T00:13
at 2007-12-29T00:13

By Hedwig
at 2007-12-29T03:49
at 2007-12-29T03:49

By Zenobia
at 2008-01-02T10:24
at 2008-01-02T10:24

By Noah
at 2008-01-03T04:28
at 2008-01-03T04:28

By Joseph
at 2008-01-06T22:07
at 2008-01-06T22:07

By John
at 2008-01-07T17:22
at 2008-01-07T17:22

By Wallis
at 2008-01-08T15:44
at 2008-01-08T15:44

By Michael
at 2008-01-11T22:50
at 2008-01-11T22:50

By Edith
at 2008-01-15T01:13
at 2008-01-15T01:13

By Freda
at 2008-01-18T13:45
at 2008-01-18T13:45

By Vanessa
at 2008-01-20T11:51
at 2008-01-20T11:51

By Jessica
at 2008-01-24T16:02
at 2008-01-24T16:02

By Audriana
at 2008-01-25T17:06
at 2008-01-25T17:06

By Xanthe
at 2008-01-28T02:43
at 2008-01-28T02:43

By Kristin
at 2008-02-01T13:44
at 2008-02-01T13:44

By Todd Johnson
at 2008-02-05T20:47
at 2008-02-05T20:47

By Eden
at 2008-02-09T03:19
at 2008-02-09T03:19

By Jessica
at 2008-02-12T21:44
at 2008-02-12T21:44

By Carolina Franco
at 2008-02-15T13:17
at 2008-02-15T13:17

By Susan
at 2008-02-16T17:31
at 2008-02-16T17:31

By Catherine
at 2008-02-18T17:43
at 2008-02-18T17:43

By Jacob
at 2008-02-22T09:36
at 2008-02-22T09:36

By Emma
at 2008-02-24T23:29
at 2008-02-24T23:29

By Carol
at 2008-02-25T23:06
at 2008-02-25T23:06

By Cara
at 2008-02-29T19:43
at 2008-02-29T19:43

By Liam
at 2008-03-04T03:58
at 2008-03-04T03:58

By Mia
at 2008-03-07T10:58
at 2008-03-07T10:58

By Elma
at 2008-03-08T07:38
at 2008-03-08T07:38

By Kumar
at 2008-03-09T09:07
at 2008-03-09T09:07

By Ivy
at 2008-03-09T10:49
at 2008-03-09T10:49

By Regina
at 2008-03-11T06:53
at 2008-03-11T06:53

By Gilbert
at 2008-03-14T10:58
at 2008-03-14T10:58

By Heather
at 2008-03-18T15:44
at 2008-03-18T15:44

By Lucy
at 2008-03-21T17:29
at 2008-03-21T17:29

By Lydia
at 2008-03-22T12:29
at 2008-03-22T12:29

By Caitlin
at 2008-03-23T22:55
at 2008-03-23T22:55

By Hardy
at 2008-03-26T13:53
at 2008-03-26T13:53

By Caitlin
at 2008-03-26T21:42
at 2008-03-26T21:42

By Agatha
at 2008-03-27T13:37
at 2008-03-27T13:37

By Puput
at 2008-03-28T01:59
at 2008-03-28T01:59

By Kelly
at 2008-03-28T15:50
at 2008-03-28T15:50

By Elvira
at 2008-03-31T01:06
at 2008-03-31T01:06

By Blanche
at 2008-04-03T16:21
at 2008-04-03T16:21

By Olivia
at 2008-04-04T10:07
at 2008-04-04T10:07

By Leila
at 2008-04-05T20:48
at 2008-04-05T20:48

By Lauren
at 2008-04-08T16:58
at 2008-04-08T16:58

By Frederic
at 2008-04-09T03:10
at 2008-04-09T03:10

By Rebecca
at 2008-04-12T01:26
at 2008-04-12T01:26

By Mia
at 2008-04-12T15:50
at 2008-04-12T15:50

By Genevieve
at 2008-04-16T23:41
at 2008-04-16T23:41

By Jessica
at 2008-04-19T11:21
at 2008-04-19T11:21

By Ivy
at 2008-04-21T18:42
at 2008-04-21T18:42

By Callum
at 2008-04-22T20:29
at 2008-04-22T20:29

By Kelly
at 2008-04-25T13:01
at 2008-04-25T13:01

By Yedda
at 2008-04-30T05:27
at 2008-04-30T05:27

By John
at 2008-05-03T19:52
at 2008-05-03T19:52

By Hazel
at 2008-05-04T11:07
at 2008-05-04T11:07
Related Posts
[寧靜海影談] 色戒 Lust, Caution(含劇情)

By Connor
at 2007-10-07T13:38
at 2007-10-07T13:38
樊光耀為愛哭鬼李安辯解 拍色戒壓力大 댠…

By Jacky
at 2007-10-07T00:34
at 2007-10-07T00:34
CNN專訪李安談【色,戒】 李安:「激넠…

By Iris
at 2007-10-07T00:34
at 2007-10-07T00:34
【色,戒】美國部分影評差 陳沖:意料 …

By Rae
at 2007-10-07T00:33
at 2007-10-07T00:33
【色,戒】讓他突破成突變?李安:我本質不變

By Kelly
at 2007-10-07T00:13
at 2007-10-07T00:13