九回時間旅行的結局(有雷) - 韓劇
By Callum
at 2013-05-15T17:23
at 2013-05-15T17:23
Table of Contents
看完頭好痛,太混亂了,個人認為是
兩個時空(或說多個時空)兩種結局
時空A(大善宇)2013.4
大善宇用了最後一炷香回到1993年,改變了過去(時空A的現在也跟著被影響),最後卻被
鎖在1993且死在1993。所以時空A時間繼續推進下去,是個悲劇。即便一切都恢復正常,
哥哥正宇也沒死,且崔正哲變得一無所有(後來還車禍掛掉),但是在時空A中善宇的定位
是早在20年前就被崔正哲給撞死了。
這樣結局也有謬誤,善宇既然在20年前就被撞死,之後的世界怎麼還會有善宇跟敏英的婚
禮。
時空B(小善宇)1993~2012
小善宇因大善宇的幫助之下(避開腦瘤、哥哥認罪、讓崔受到制裁),人生一路順遂,即便
最後他從敏英口中得知那個從未來穿越過來的自己死在當時1993自己的年代,其實也無所
謂。因為依照編劇假定香只有9支的原則下,9支香用完就沒了,因此他沒有香回到過去,
所以不會死在過去。在這個時空中是個happy ending,男女主角可以過著幸福快樂的日子
。
最後雪山的那幕完全不想理他,根本亂演= = (自相矛盾)
假設這一幕是時空A之下,也就是回到第一集,有一個老善宇來救了未認罪的正宇,正宇
就不會死了。這樣一來就會推翻後面所演的(即後面所演的正宇死在河裡手中握香),邏輯
錯誤。
假設這一幕是時空B之下。在時空B下的正宇已認罪,根本沒有找香的動機(時空A的正宇是
因為當初殺了養父沒認罪,想回到過去阻止悲劇發生)。即便他無意間知道有香的存在要
去找香,但是在編劇假定的原則下(兩個時空共用9隻香,用完就沒了),香早就沒了,而
那一幕正宇手中還握有香,又違背了編劇的假定,邏輯錯誤。
結論:
前面非常精彩但是後面爛尾了。我覺得最好的結局就是男主角不要被卡在過去,能
回到時空A跟朱敏英結婚,這樣後面就不會有一堆難以理解的劇情了。穿越劇本來就會有
一堆漏洞難以解釋,很容易出現多個時空與多個輪迴。
有興趣詳見:http://ppt.cc/_~sh
--
Tags:
韓劇
All Comments
By Caroline
at 2013-05-17T17:07
at 2013-05-17T17:07
By Isla
at 2013-05-22T07:55
at 2013-05-22T07:55
By Elma
at 2013-05-25T10:39
at 2013-05-25T10:39
By Sierra Rose
at 2013-05-27T12:22
at 2013-05-27T12:22
By Carolina Franco
at 2013-05-30T17:13
at 2013-05-30T17:13
By Andrew
at 2013-06-02T03:33
at 2013-06-02T03:33
By Ethan
at 2013-06-02T07:39
at 2013-06-02T07:39
By Catherine
at 2013-06-03T22:11
at 2013-06-03T22:11
By George
at 2013-06-06T16:23
at 2013-06-06T16:23
By Daniel
at 2013-06-08T23:55
at 2013-06-08T23:55
By Regina
at 2013-06-12T01:19
at 2013-06-12T01:19
By Cara
at 2013-06-17T01:02
at 2013-06-17T01:02
By Hamiltion
at 2013-06-19T17:54
at 2013-06-19T17:54
By Jake
at 2013-06-22T06:08
at 2013-06-22T06:08
By Mary
at 2013-06-25T01:10
at 2013-06-25T01:10
By Barb Cronin
at 2013-06-28T23:15
at 2013-06-28T23:15
By Adele
at 2013-07-01T03:36
at 2013-07-01T03:36
By Noah
at 2013-07-03T07:27
at 2013-07-03T07:27
By Anthony
at 2013-07-05T01:12
at 2013-07-05T01:12
By Zanna
at 2013-07-09T14:23
at 2013-07-09T14:23
By Annie
at 2013-07-12T00:19
at 2013-07-12T00:19
By Aaliyah
at 2013-07-14T15:14
at 2013-07-14T15:14
By Xanthe
at 2013-07-18T08:01
at 2013-07-18T08:01
By Barb Cronin
at 2013-07-23T03:21
at 2013-07-23T03:21
By Lauren
at 2013-07-26T03:46
at 2013-07-26T03:46
By Skylar DavisLinda
at 2013-07-29T02:16
at 2013-07-29T02:16
By Caitlin
at 2013-08-02T06:39
at 2013-08-02T06:39
By Megan
at 2013-08-03T07:35
at 2013-08-03T07:35
By Todd Johnson
at 2013-08-07T12:01
at 2013-08-07T12:01
By Freda
at 2013-08-08T13:32
at 2013-08-08T13:32
By Enid
at 2013-08-10T13:45
at 2013-08-10T13:45
By Lydia
at 2013-08-14T13:32
at 2013-08-14T13:32
By Xanthe
at 2013-08-16T22:10
at 2013-08-16T22:10
By Odelette
at 2013-08-20T22:21
at 2013-08-20T22:21
By Cara
at 2013-08-24T06:51
at 2013-08-24T06:51
By Edward Lewis
at 2013-08-28T23:01
at 2013-08-28T23:01
By William
at 2013-09-02T03:35
at 2013-09-02T03:35
By Tristan Cohan
at 2013-09-05T09:48
at 2013-09-05T09:48
By Carolina Franco
at 2013-09-08T20:13
at 2013-09-08T20:13
By Hedwig
at 2013-09-09T21:44
at 2013-09-09T21:44
By James
at 2013-09-13T08:03
at 2013-09-13T08:03
By Madame
at 2013-09-14T13:54
at 2013-09-14T13:54
By John
at 2013-09-17T11:28
at 2013-09-17T11:28
By Emily
at 2013-09-19T12:20
at 2013-09-19T12:20
By Elvira
at 2013-09-22T11:21
at 2013-09-22T11:21
By Leila
at 2013-09-23T05:29
at 2013-09-23T05:29
By Hamiltion
at 2013-09-23T18:36
at 2013-09-23T18:36
By Zora
at 2013-09-25T02:22
at 2013-09-25T02:22
By Quanna
at 2013-09-26T04:42
at 2013-09-26T04:42
By David
at 2013-09-30T07:56
at 2013-09-30T07:56
By Edith
at 2013-10-03T00:28
at 2013-10-03T00:28
By Donna
at 2013-10-04T08:10
at 2013-10-04T08:10
By Selena
at 2013-10-04T09:48
at 2013-10-04T09:48
By Thomas
at 2013-10-08T15:36
at 2013-10-08T15:36
By Joe
at 2013-10-12T07:24
at 2013-10-12T07:24
By Isabella
at 2013-10-16T14:57
at 2013-10-16T14:57
Related Posts
張玉貞 為愛而生 EP12(帶一點11)
By Kyle
at 2013-05-15T14:23
at 2013-05-15T14:23
金宇彬 加入 "繼承人們" 再次攜手金編
By Hedda
at 2013-05-15T12:46
at 2013-05-15T12:46
金素妍將攜手李準基出演《 Two weeks》
By Madame
at 2013-05-15T12:31
at 2013-05-15T12:31
男女主角初識相遇超荒謬滑稽有哪幾部戲?
By Xanthe
at 2013-05-15T11:25
at 2013-05-15T11:25
幸福的反擊 真爛
By Dorothy
at 2013-05-15T03:27
at 2013-05-15T03:27