想為周芷若平反一下 - 華視

By Kelly
at 2010-01-26T22:16
at 2010-01-26T22:16
Table of Contents
這版本倚天普遍對演周芷若存有偏見
演員劉競不夠美麗
其實我覺得是髮型的問題。
劉競實在不適合盤起頭髮,
很多幕把頭髮放下來的鏡頭都會覺得她美麗許多
其實周芷若這個角色自有倚天以來就一直和趙敏這個角色爭論不休
爭論的點在於哪一個比較討喜
這個版本很明顯周芷若不是個討喜的角色
可是這和整個戲劇的走向很有關係
周芷若和趙敏都是陰險的蛇蝎美人角
一個聰明伶俐、一個悲苦柔弱應該是林黛玉那種類型的角色
這是這兩個角色不同的角色魅力,完美詮釋才能夠讓觀眾
對於她們陰險的一面視而不見
而安以軒很到位的做到了聰明伶俐這一點
劉競卻沒有給人柔弱想保護的感覺
但這究竟是她自己演技上的不足...
亦或是導演要求的戲劇走向呢?
這個不得而知,總之戲劇呈現出來的效果就是這樣了
大家想一想
她自小就失去雙親、她被搶婚、她被逼迫立下滅絕要求的毒誓
她被拱為峨嵋掌門人要光復門派、她的師父被趙敏害死(對她而言)
她應該是個徹頭徹尾的苦情角色
可是怎麼看著這齣戲卻沒有給我們絲毫苦情的感覺呢?
這到底是劉競的問題還是導演的問題?
導演是不是想塑造一個不討喜的角色?
--
演員劉競不夠美麗
其實我覺得是髮型的問題。
劉競實在不適合盤起頭髮,
很多幕把頭髮放下來的鏡頭都會覺得她美麗許多
其實周芷若這個角色自有倚天以來就一直和趙敏這個角色爭論不休
爭論的點在於哪一個比較討喜
這個版本很明顯周芷若不是個討喜的角色
可是這和整個戲劇的走向很有關係
周芷若和趙敏都是陰險的蛇蝎美人角
一個聰明伶俐、一個悲苦柔弱應該是林黛玉那種類型的角色
這是這兩個角色不同的角色魅力,完美詮釋才能夠讓觀眾
對於她們陰險的一面視而不見
而安以軒很到位的做到了聰明伶俐這一點
劉競卻沒有給人柔弱想保護的感覺
但這究竟是她自己演技上的不足...
亦或是導演要求的戲劇走向呢?
這個不得而知,總之戲劇呈現出來的效果就是這樣了
大家想一想
她自小就失去雙親、她被搶婚、她被逼迫立下滅絕要求的毒誓
她被拱為峨嵋掌門人要光復門派、她的師父被趙敏害死(對她而言)
她應該是個徹頭徹尾的苦情角色
可是怎麼看著這齣戲卻沒有給我們絲毫苦情的感覺呢?
這到底是劉競的問題還是導演的問題?
導演是不是想塑造一個不討喜的角色?
--
Tags:
華視
All Comments

By Lydia
at 2010-01-31T11:40
at 2010-01-31T11:40

By Lauren
at 2010-02-05T09:54
at 2010-02-05T09:54

By Frederic
at 2010-02-06T18:41
at 2010-02-06T18:41

By Jacky
at 2010-02-10T19:24
at 2010-02-10T19:24

By Dora
at 2010-02-14T01:32
at 2010-02-14T01:32

By Kelly
at 2010-02-18T17:10
at 2010-02-18T17:10

By Zora
at 2010-02-21T21:30
at 2010-02-21T21:30

By Agatha
at 2010-02-22T13:37
at 2010-02-22T13:37

By Jacob
at 2010-02-26T15:57
at 2010-02-26T15:57

By Quanna
at 2010-03-02T08:55
at 2010-03-02T08:55

By Freda
at 2010-03-06T17:28
at 2010-03-06T17:28

By Xanthe
at 2010-03-07T06:59
at 2010-03-07T06:59

By Linda
at 2010-03-09T13:51
at 2010-03-09T13:51

By David
at 2010-03-14T01:58
at 2010-03-14T01:58

By Xanthe
at 2010-03-15T21:45
at 2010-03-15T21:45

By Caroline
at 2010-03-20T01:15
at 2010-03-20T01:15

By Harry
at 2010-03-21T05:25
at 2010-03-21T05:25

By Ina
at 2010-03-25T13:19
at 2010-03-25T13:19

By Ophelia
at 2010-03-28T08:52
at 2010-03-28T08:52

By Caroline
at 2010-03-31T15:31
at 2010-03-31T15:31

By Thomas
at 2010-04-01T18:39
at 2010-04-01T18:39

By Ophelia
at 2010-04-06T17:18
at 2010-04-06T17:18

By Michael
at 2010-04-08T08:57
at 2010-04-08T08:57

By Tom
at 2010-04-09T12:58
at 2010-04-09T12:58

By Odelette
at 2010-04-11T01:47
at 2010-04-11T01:47

By Odelette
at 2010-04-13T22:00
at 2010-04-13T22:00

By Irma
at 2010-04-16T20:42
at 2010-04-16T20:42

By Blanche
at 2010-04-19T20:13
at 2010-04-19T20:13

By Hedda
at 2010-04-21T06:18
at 2010-04-21T06:18

By Elma
at 2010-04-24T14:34
at 2010-04-24T14:34

By Andrew
at 2010-04-28T19:36
at 2010-04-28T19:36

By Necoo
at 2010-05-01T23:35
at 2010-05-01T23:35

By Tristan Cohan
at 2010-05-02T08:49
at 2010-05-02T08:49

By Connor
at 2010-05-03T20:46
at 2010-05-03T20:46

By Zora
at 2010-05-07T09:55
at 2010-05-07T09:55

By Charlotte
at 2010-05-12T06:24
at 2010-05-12T06:24

By Jacky
at 2010-05-14T06:02
at 2010-05-14T06:02

By Andrew
at 2010-05-16T15:58
at 2010-05-16T15:58

By Todd Johnson
at 2010-05-17T11:48
at 2010-05-17T11:48

By Dorothy
at 2010-05-19T17:27
at 2010-05-19T17:27

By John
at 2010-05-21T14:25
at 2010-05-21T14:25

By Anonymous
at 2010-05-22T10:17
at 2010-05-22T10:17

By Isabella
at 2010-05-23T22:43
at 2010-05-23T22:43

By Valerie
at 2010-05-26T21:10
at 2010-05-26T21:10

By Hedda
at 2010-05-27T11:38
at 2010-05-27T11:38

By Audriana
at 2010-05-31T14:54
at 2010-05-31T14:54

By Valerie
at 2010-06-03T21:59
at 2010-06-03T21:59

By Edith
at 2010-06-04T19:03
at 2010-06-04T19:03

By Suhail Hany
at 2010-06-08T16:52
at 2010-06-08T16:52

By Franklin
at 2010-06-11T15:52
at 2010-06-11T15:52

By Dinah
at 2010-06-14T01:18
at 2010-06-14T01:18

By Charlie
at 2010-06-14T19:17
at 2010-06-14T19:17

By Aaliyah
at 2010-06-18T23:24
at 2010-06-18T23:24

By Callum
at 2010-06-20T00:07
at 2010-06-20T00:07

By Jack
at 2010-06-23T16:58
at 2010-06-23T16:58

By Doris
at 2010-06-24T02:15
at 2010-06-24T02:15

By Daph Bay
at 2010-06-28T05:43
at 2010-06-28T05:43

By Genevieve
at 2010-06-30T11:08
at 2010-06-30T11:08

By Wallis
at 2010-07-04T05:06
at 2010-07-04T05:06

By Anonymous
at 2010-07-06T09:56
at 2010-07-06T09:56

By Olga
at 2010-07-09T20:02
at 2010-07-09T20:02

By Rebecca
at 2010-07-11T10:00
at 2010-07-11T10:00

By Yuri
at 2010-07-14T10:41
at 2010-07-14T10:41

By Hedda
at 2010-07-16T07:11
at 2010-07-16T07:11

By Regina
at 2010-07-19T14:42
at 2010-07-19T14:42

By James
at 2010-07-23T08:50
at 2010-07-23T08:50

By Hedwig
at 2010-07-28T01:26
at 2010-07-28T01:26

By Heather
at 2010-07-30T03:52
at 2010-07-30T03:52

By Vanessa
at 2010-08-01T18:24
at 2010-08-01T18:24

By Agatha
at 2010-08-06T08:17
at 2010-08-06T08:17

By Susan
at 2010-08-07T08:38
at 2010-08-07T08:38

By Isla
at 2010-08-07T18:34
at 2010-08-07T18:34

By Ivy
at 2010-08-09T16:18
at 2010-08-09T16:18

By Margaret
at 2010-08-09T18:09
at 2010-08-09T18:09

By Franklin
at 2010-08-11T08:37
at 2010-08-11T08:37

By Valerie
at 2010-08-13T12:27
at 2010-08-13T12:27

By Hardy
at 2010-08-14T06:40
at 2010-08-14T06:40

By Genevieve
at 2010-08-15T06:49
at 2010-08-15T06:49

By Rachel
at 2010-08-19T23:05
at 2010-08-19T23:05

By Dora
at 2010-08-21T18:03
at 2010-08-21T18:03

By Anonymous
at 2010-08-24T22:26
at 2010-08-24T22:26

By Hedda
at 2010-08-26T13:40
at 2010-08-26T13:40

By Emma
at 2010-08-27T06:33
at 2010-08-27T06:33

By Kelly
at 2010-08-30T03:11
at 2010-08-30T03:11

By Christine
at 2010-09-03T22:39
at 2010-09-03T22:39

By Queena
at 2010-09-05T18:24
at 2010-09-05T18:24

By Necoo
at 2010-09-10T01:18
at 2010-09-10T01:18

By Lydia
at 2010-09-10T12:21
at 2010-09-10T12:21

By Hedda
at 2010-09-11T17:18
at 2010-09-11T17:18

By Tom
at 2010-09-12T09:38
at 2010-09-12T09:38

By Candice
at 2010-09-15T01:14
at 2010-09-15T01:14

By Jack
at 2010-09-17T18:40
at 2010-09-17T18:40

By Todd Johnson
at 2010-09-19T16:33
at 2010-09-19T16:33

By Queena
at 2010-09-22T10:16
at 2010-09-22T10:16

By Rae
at 2010-09-22T20:31
at 2010-09-22T20:31

By Elizabeth
at 2010-09-27T14:59
at 2010-09-27T14:59

By Una
at 2010-09-30T19:54
at 2010-09-30T19:54

By Andy
at 2010-10-03T05:00
at 2010-10-03T05:00

By Elizabeth
at 2010-10-07T01:12
at 2010-10-07T01:12

By Victoria
at 2010-10-07T21:05
at 2010-10-07T21:05

By Kelly
at 2010-10-11T17:41
at 2010-10-11T17:41

By Frederic
at 2010-10-16T03:02
at 2010-10-16T03:02

By Kumar
at 2010-10-20T15:55
at 2010-10-20T15:55

By Hamiltion
at 2010-10-23T12:32
at 2010-10-23T12:32

By Aaliyah
at 2010-10-26T01:49
at 2010-10-26T01:49

By Quintina
at 2010-10-26T13:47
at 2010-10-26T13:47

By Edwina
at 2010-10-30T19:40
at 2010-10-30T19:40

By Wallis
at 2010-11-01T10:23
at 2010-11-01T10:23

By Freda
at 2010-11-05T12:41
at 2010-11-05T12:41

By Hazel
at 2010-11-05T14:36
at 2010-11-05T14:36

By Lydia
at 2010-11-06T03:20
at 2010-11-06T03:20

By Adele
at 2010-11-09T04:25
at 2010-11-09T04:25

By Agnes
at 2010-11-14T00:18
at 2010-11-14T00:18

By Edith
at 2010-11-17T21:10
at 2010-11-17T21:10

By Brianna
at 2010-11-20T12:28
at 2010-11-20T12:28

By Ivy
at 2010-11-23T16:29
at 2010-11-23T16:29

By Audriana
at 2010-11-27T02:49
at 2010-11-27T02:49

By Lauren
at 2010-11-28T00:00
at 2010-11-28T00:00

By Robert
at 2010-12-01T19:46
at 2010-12-01T19:46

By Jessica
at 2010-12-04T10:35
at 2010-12-04T10:35

By Andrew
at 2010-12-04T18:25
at 2010-12-04T18:25

By Rae
at 2010-12-05T01:43
at 2010-12-05T01:43

By Dora
at 2010-12-09T09:47
at 2010-12-09T09:47

By Adele
at 2010-12-12T21:27
at 2010-12-12T21:27

By Daniel
at 2010-12-14T21:45
at 2010-12-14T21:45

By Zanna
at 2010-12-16T23:17
at 2010-12-16T23:17

By Noah
at 2010-12-17T07:24
at 2010-12-17T07:24

By Tom
at 2010-12-19T20:47
at 2010-12-19T20:47

By Genevieve
at 2010-12-21T11:13
at 2010-12-21T11:13

By Aaliyah
at 2010-12-24T18:47
at 2010-12-24T18:47

By Annie
at 2010-12-29T06:11
at 2010-12-29T06:11

By David
at 2011-01-01T09:01
at 2011-01-01T09:01

By Jacky
at 2011-01-05T03:00
at 2011-01-05T03:00

By Ethan
at 2011-01-07T15:10
at 2011-01-07T15:10

By Rebecca
at 2011-01-09T04:03
at 2011-01-09T04:03

By Heather
at 2011-01-11T19:22
at 2011-01-11T19:22

By Skylar DavisLinda
at 2011-01-13T19:42
at 2011-01-13T19:42

By Iris
at 2011-01-14T15:34
at 2011-01-14T15:34

By Jack
at 2011-01-15T01:06
at 2011-01-15T01:06

By Iris
at 2011-01-16T02:21
at 2011-01-16T02:21

By Ethan
at 2011-01-19T18:43
at 2011-01-19T18:43

By Erin
at 2011-01-22T00:07
at 2011-01-22T00:07

By Sarah
at 2011-01-25T08:28
at 2011-01-25T08:28

By Edwina
at 2011-01-29T16:41
at 2011-01-29T16:41

By Elvira
at 2011-01-30T20:10
at 2011-01-30T20:10

By Hedwig
at 2011-02-01T02:49
at 2011-02-01T02:49

By Charlotte
at 2011-02-04T01:57
at 2011-02-04T01:57

By Audriana
at 2011-02-06T16:43
at 2011-02-06T16:43

By Selena
at 2011-02-09T11:51
at 2011-02-09T11:51

By Michael
at 2011-02-12T05:10
at 2011-02-12T05:10

By Gary
at 2011-02-16T09:59
at 2011-02-16T09:59

By Lydia
at 2011-02-17T13:18
at 2011-02-17T13:18

By Frederic
at 2011-02-22T04:27
at 2011-02-22T04:27

By Franklin
at 2011-02-27T01:01
at 2011-02-27T01:01

By Connor
at 2011-03-02T03:38
at 2011-03-02T03:38

By Margaret
at 2011-03-06T22:58
at 2011-03-06T22:58

By Rae
at 2011-03-08T20:53
at 2011-03-08T20:53

By Sandy
at 2011-03-09T06:54
at 2011-03-09T06:54

By Jessica
at 2011-03-12T20:45
at 2011-03-12T20:45

By Kama
at 2011-03-15T14:38
at 2011-03-15T14:38

By Ethan
at 2011-03-18T12:10
at 2011-03-18T12:10

By Ethan
at 2011-03-22T05:10
at 2011-03-22T05:10

By Blanche
at 2011-03-26T01:27
at 2011-03-26T01:27

By Hazel
at 2011-03-27T14:42
at 2011-03-27T14:42

By Lauren
at 2011-03-29T14:06
at 2011-03-29T14:06

By Poppy
at 2011-03-30T10:44
at 2011-03-30T10:44

By Lauren
at 2011-04-03T06:32
at 2011-04-03T06:32

By Oscar
at 2011-04-03T22:24
at 2011-04-03T22:24

By Cara
at 2011-04-06T09:21
at 2011-04-06T09:21

By Dora
at 2011-04-09T12:03
at 2011-04-09T12:03

By Ethan
at 2011-04-14T03:19
at 2011-04-14T03:19

By Edward Lewis
at 2011-04-16T05:36
at 2011-04-16T05:36

By Connor
at 2011-04-17T16:17
at 2011-04-17T16:17

By Edith
at 2011-04-22T08:05
at 2011-04-22T08:05

By Frederic
at 2011-04-26T02:32
at 2011-04-26T02:32

By Frederica
at 2011-04-27T02:30
at 2011-04-27T02:30

By Frederica
at 2011-04-30T08:25
at 2011-04-30T08:25

By Blanche
at 2011-05-01T23:50
at 2011-05-01T23:50

By Heather
at 2011-05-05T09:33
at 2011-05-05T09:33

By Freda
at 2011-05-06T13:19
at 2011-05-06T13:19

By Tom
at 2011-05-08T05:44
at 2011-05-08T05:44

By Ophelia
at 2011-05-11T17:44
at 2011-05-11T17:44

By Ida
at 2011-05-13T14:52
at 2011-05-13T14:52

By Victoria
at 2011-05-15T23:10
at 2011-05-15T23:10

By Rae
at 2011-05-16T14:43
at 2011-05-16T14:43

By Caroline
at 2011-05-20T19:56
at 2011-05-20T19:56

By Margaret
at 2011-05-22T20:25
at 2011-05-22T20:25

By Ophelia
at 2011-05-24T09:00
at 2011-05-24T09:00

By Eden
at 2011-05-24T21:15
at 2011-05-24T21:15

By Anonymous
at 2011-05-27T03:47
at 2011-05-27T03:47

By Oscar
at 2011-05-30T17:03
at 2011-05-30T17:03

By Frederic
at 2011-06-01T02:48
at 2011-06-01T02:48

By Zora
at 2011-06-03T14:53
at 2011-06-03T14:53

By Doris
at 2011-06-04T10:38
at 2011-06-04T10:38

By Anthony
at 2011-06-07T12:16
at 2011-06-07T12:16

By Olga
at 2011-06-09T16:57
at 2011-06-09T16:57

By Joseph
at 2011-06-13T14:13
at 2011-06-13T14:13

By Tracy
at 2011-06-14T14:35
at 2011-06-14T14:35

By Tom
at 2011-06-14T16:35
at 2011-06-14T16:35

By Anthony
at 2011-06-15T18:28
at 2011-06-15T18:28

By Elizabeth
at 2011-06-19T04:10
at 2011-06-19T04:10

By Dorothy
at 2011-06-23T04:41
at 2011-06-23T04:41

By Wallis
at 2011-06-25T07:08
at 2011-06-25T07:08

By Ivy
at 2011-06-26T19:28
at 2011-06-26T19:28

By Connor
at 2011-06-30T12:53
at 2011-06-30T12:53

By Dinah
at 2011-07-04T00:04
at 2011-07-04T00:04

By Jake
at 2011-07-07T20:33
at 2011-07-07T20:33

By Rae
at 2011-07-10T04:22
at 2011-07-10T04:22

By Andrew
at 2011-07-13T13:37
at 2011-07-13T13:37

By Susan
at 2011-07-17T23:01
at 2011-07-17T23:01

By Emily
at 2011-07-20T12:09
at 2011-07-20T12:09

By Damian
at 2011-07-21T09:18
at 2011-07-21T09:18
Related Posts
新倚天屠龍記~第18集

By Michael
at 2010-01-26T19:48
at 2010-01-26T19:48
有關倚天屠龍

By Susan
at 2010-01-25T20:17
at 2010-01-25T20:17
新倚天屠龍記~第17集

By Madame
at 2010-01-25T19:52
at 2010-01-25T19:52
2010/01/18~2010/01/24 AGB尼爾森收視率

By Edith
at 2010-01-25T19:47
at 2010-01-25T19:47
《熊貓人》相關網站

By Gary
at 2010-01-25T15:29
at 2010-01-25T15:29