料理鼠王:一窺皮克斯(Pixar)的弱點(雷) - 電影

By Edith
at 2007-08-06T09:34
at 2007-08-06T09:34
Table of Contents
料理鼠王,表現出了皮克斯(Pixar) 動畫的缺點。
料理鼠王(Ratatouille)到底出了什麼問題呢?
我想料理鼠王與過去皮克斯的電影,最大不同在於:題材的靜態感與復雜度。
過去皮克斯成功的電影王牌模式,大概可以分為「簡單的主線劇情」+「熱鬧的動作場面
」。像是為我認為當年最佳電影的”海底總動員”來說,劇情就是「爸爸救兒子」+「一
路上精彩動感的歷險過程」。廣受我朋友歡迎的”超人總動員”,也是「兒女救爸媽」+
「一路上精彩動感的歷險過程」。
料理鼠王在劇情上面對的是一個非常靜態且無形的東西:味道。”味道”天生上就比較難
以表現,而且並非皮克斯所擅長的題材。皮克斯也試著用各種手法來將”味道”有形化,
但是似乎都僅限於皮毛而沒有深入的演出。
在表現”味道”上,電影中有二次為皮克斯用迪士尼”幻想曲”的風格,將味道用「顏色
」與「煙火圖形」來加以表現。在這二次的電影片斷裡,我覺得表現的很好。可惜是皮克
斯並沒有擅用這個成功的表演方式將它擴大,而僅僅只是曇花一現,並沒有讓觀眾對老鼠
所做出來的”味道”有特別深的印象。
最後皮克斯選擇了「烘焙王」(某漫畫,前13集很好看,還有卡通)或是「小當家」的表現
方式,來呈現料理的味道。像是最後給美食評論家吃下法國窮困鄉下才吃的雜菜煲,讓評
論家意起了小時候母親的味道。這種表現手法早在各種漫畫卡通中出現過無數次,而且”
料理鼠王”的表現也一點都不精彩。本片的英文名字「Ratatouille」的原意為” 燉燜蔬
菜(內含茄子、洋蔥、番茄、青椒、義大利絲瓜等)”,就是指最後做給美食評論家的雜菜
煲,結果表現手法如此平淡,真是非常無力。相同的表現手法,”烘焙王”要有意思的多
了。
料理鼠王的劇情復雜度,也遠遠超過皮克斯所能承受的範圍。原本要讓不能溝通的人與鼠
互相產生關聯,甚至發展出深厚的友誼,就是一件很難的事情。本片的下場就是劇情發展
非常唐突,甚至連算是人類之間的男女主角愛情,都讓人覺得丈二金鋼摸不著腦袋的忽然
發生。有些特別的伏筆也沒有處理好,像是廚師們之間的背景關係,美食評論家的仇視原
因,甚至連壞人都不夠壞。最慘的是貫通本片的主句「料理非難事」,也是在片中無法有
任何的感覺……看完後只覺得料理真的蠻難的,XD
皮克斯最拿手的快動作熱鬧場面,受限於本片題材而發揮有限,所以連一點挽救的機會都
沒有。尤其最後眾多老鼠來煮菜的片斷沒有好好的發揮,更讓人覺得可惜。
由料理鼠王的表現來看,皮克斯所擅長的題材似乎有所限制。或許在暑假可以帶小朋友看
個中文版不錯,但是不太推薦給希望有個快樂下午的情侶們。
--
我的blog,懷念的山外幫
http://blog.pixnet.net/djboylee
--
Tags:
電影
All Comments

By Ivy
at 2007-08-08T09:15
at 2007-08-08T09:15

By Suhail Hany
at 2007-08-09T20:18
at 2007-08-09T20:18

By Jessica
at 2007-08-12T14:45
at 2007-08-12T14:45

By Andy
at 2007-08-16T14:02
at 2007-08-16T14:02

By Enid
at 2007-08-20T09:42
at 2007-08-20T09:42

By Margaret
at 2007-08-23T01:43
at 2007-08-23T01:43

By Noah
at 2007-08-27T03:02
at 2007-08-27T03:02

By Emma
at 2007-09-01T02:00
at 2007-09-01T02:00

By Tristan Cohan
at 2007-09-05T13:06
at 2007-09-05T13:06

By Enid
at 2007-09-08T19:30
at 2007-09-08T19:30

By Victoria
at 2007-09-11T21:15
at 2007-09-11T21:15

By Cara
at 2007-09-16T09:59
at 2007-09-16T09:59

By Daph Bay
at 2007-09-16T22:04
at 2007-09-16T22:04

By Ina
at 2007-09-18T04:53
at 2007-09-18T04:53

By Emma
at 2007-09-19T05:02
at 2007-09-19T05:02

By Anonymous
at 2007-09-20T02:44
at 2007-09-20T02:44

By Emily
at 2007-09-23T16:39
at 2007-09-23T16:39

By Kumar
at 2007-09-25T06:58
at 2007-09-25T06:58

By Anthony
at 2007-09-30T04:36
at 2007-09-30T04:36

By Frederica
at 2007-10-01T06:04
at 2007-10-01T06:04

By Vanessa
at 2007-10-03T15:11
at 2007-10-03T15:11

By Edwina
at 2007-10-04T18:03
at 2007-10-04T18:03

By Lauren
at 2007-10-06T11:18
at 2007-10-06T11:18

By Linda
at 2007-10-08T10:04
at 2007-10-08T10:04

By Michael
at 2007-10-11T01:51
at 2007-10-11T01:51

By Lydia
at 2007-10-13T20:15
at 2007-10-13T20:15

By Kyle
at 2007-10-15T17:00
at 2007-10-15T17:00

By Agnes
at 2007-10-20T02:03
at 2007-10-20T02:03

By Iris
at 2007-10-20T21:37
at 2007-10-20T21:37

By Dorothy
at 2007-10-23T15:34
at 2007-10-23T15:34

By Ida
at 2007-10-27T16:20
at 2007-10-27T16:20

By Queena
at 2007-10-28T18:47
at 2007-10-28T18:47

By Lucy
at 2007-10-30T03:40
at 2007-10-30T03:40

By Queena
at 2007-11-03T21:02
at 2007-11-03T21:02

By Belly
at 2007-11-08T08:38
at 2007-11-08T08:38

By Enid
at 2007-11-11T23:52
at 2007-11-11T23:52

By Zora
at 2007-11-13T08:19
at 2007-11-13T08:19

By Hamiltion
at 2007-11-15T13:02
at 2007-11-15T13:02

By Ethan
at 2007-11-18T15:35
at 2007-11-18T15:35

By Megan
at 2007-11-19T06:36
at 2007-11-19T06:36

By Isabella
at 2007-11-20T04:57
at 2007-11-20T04:57

By Liam
at 2007-11-22T22:36
at 2007-11-22T22:36

By Liam
at 2007-11-26T07:50
at 2007-11-26T07:50

By Olivia
at 2007-11-28T23:29
at 2007-11-28T23:29

By Agatha
at 2007-11-29T13:44
at 2007-11-29T13:44

By Franklin
at 2007-12-01T10:07
at 2007-12-01T10:07

By Robert
at 2007-12-04T16:59
at 2007-12-04T16:59

By Wallis
at 2007-12-08T16:23
at 2007-12-08T16:23

By Olga
at 2007-12-11T05:48
at 2007-12-11T05:48

By Quintina
at 2007-12-13T12:10
at 2007-12-13T12:10

By Caitlin
at 2007-12-15T20:33
at 2007-12-15T20:33

By David
at 2007-12-16T23:26
at 2007-12-16T23:26

By Suhail Hany
at 2007-12-19T22:56
at 2007-12-19T22:56

By Selena
at 2007-12-23T00:52
at 2007-12-23T00:52

By Frederica
at 2007-12-26T14:40
at 2007-12-26T14:40

By Jacob
at 2007-12-27T01:23
at 2007-12-27T01:23

By Lily
at 2007-12-27T08:38
at 2007-12-27T08:38

By David
at 2007-12-31T17:18
at 2007-12-31T17:18

By Xanthe
at 2008-01-03T20:19
at 2008-01-03T20:19

By Xanthe
at 2008-01-05T06:27
at 2008-01-05T06:27

By Victoria
at 2008-01-10T05:52
at 2008-01-10T05:52

By Dora
at 2008-01-12T12:05
at 2008-01-12T12:05

By Zenobia
at 2008-01-13T01:35
at 2008-01-13T01:35

By Eden
at 2008-01-15T09:43
at 2008-01-15T09:43

By Joseph
at 2008-01-18T14:08
at 2008-01-18T14:08

By Kristin
at 2008-01-23T05:42
at 2008-01-23T05:42

By Susan
at 2008-01-24T06:48
at 2008-01-24T06:48

By Andy
at 2008-01-25T11:32
at 2008-01-25T11:32

By George
at 2008-01-28T13:55
at 2008-01-28T13:55

By Hedda
at 2008-01-29T16:27
at 2008-01-29T16:27

By Isabella
at 2008-02-01T04:48
at 2008-02-01T04:48

By Dora
at 2008-02-03T21:53
at 2008-02-03T21:53

By Bennie
at 2008-02-07T17:49
at 2008-02-07T17:49

By Gilbert
at 2008-02-10T17:32
at 2008-02-10T17:32

By Odelette
at 2008-02-14T21:54
at 2008-02-14T21:54

By George
at 2008-02-18T16:41
at 2008-02-18T16:41

By Michael
at 2008-02-23T09:57
at 2008-02-23T09:57

By Aaliyah
at 2008-02-23T13:36
at 2008-02-23T13:36

By Charlotte
at 2008-02-28T00:25
at 2008-02-28T00:25

By Jacky
at 2008-02-29T19:18
at 2008-02-29T19:18

By Dorothy
at 2008-03-03T14:21
at 2008-03-03T14:21

By Hardy
at 2008-03-04T07:45
at 2008-03-04T07:45

By Odelette
at 2008-03-06T06:03
at 2008-03-06T06:03

By Adele
at 2008-03-10T20:06
at 2008-03-10T20:06

By Carolina Franco
at 2008-03-12T00:27
at 2008-03-12T00:27

By Madame
at 2008-03-13T02:20
at 2008-03-13T02:20

By Rosalind
at 2008-03-16T16:16
at 2008-03-16T16:16

By Hamiltion
at 2008-03-20T19:28
at 2008-03-20T19:28

By Carol
at 2008-03-20T23:39
at 2008-03-20T23:39

By Madame
at 2008-03-23T16:12
at 2008-03-23T16:12

By Agatha
at 2008-03-28T02:00
at 2008-03-28T02:00

By Frederic
at 2008-03-28T20:25
at 2008-03-28T20:25

By Mason
at 2008-03-31T10:08
at 2008-03-31T10:08

By James
at 2008-04-03T07:26
at 2008-04-03T07:26

By Steve
at 2008-04-03T20:31
at 2008-04-03T20:31

By Charlie
at 2008-04-07T16:50
at 2008-04-07T16:50

By Odelette
at 2008-04-09T10:29
at 2008-04-09T10:29

By Irma
at 2008-04-11T17:53
at 2008-04-11T17:53

By Selena
at 2008-04-12T15:58
at 2008-04-12T15:58

By Rosalind
at 2008-04-13T15:59
at 2008-04-13T15:59

By Caitlin
at 2008-04-18T08:38
at 2008-04-18T08:38

By Belly
at 2008-04-21T09:58
at 2008-04-21T09:58

By Joseph
at 2008-04-25T15:18
at 2008-04-25T15:18

By Lily
at 2008-04-27T14:43
at 2008-04-27T14:43

By Harry
at 2008-04-28T01:05
at 2008-04-28T01:05

By Thomas
at 2008-05-02T04:37
at 2008-05-02T04:37

By William
at 2008-05-05T22:43
at 2008-05-05T22:43

By Jacob
at 2008-05-10T13:32
at 2008-05-10T13:32

By Zenobia
at 2008-05-14T16:14
at 2008-05-14T16:14

By Megan
at 2008-05-16T23:55
at 2008-05-16T23:55

By Skylar Davis
at 2008-05-17T17:16
at 2008-05-17T17:16

By Skylar Davis
at 2008-05-19T19:59
at 2008-05-19T19:59

By Bennie
at 2008-05-24T06:04
at 2008-05-24T06:04

By Ophelia
at 2008-05-28T12:06
at 2008-05-28T12:06

By Jake
at 2008-06-01T01:54
at 2008-06-01T01:54

By Hedda
at 2008-06-03T15:56
at 2008-06-03T15:56

By Tom
at 2008-06-08T14:00
at 2008-06-08T14:00

By Noah
at 2008-06-09T22:12
at 2008-06-09T22:12

By Selena
at 2008-06-10T18:20
at 2008-06-10T18:20

By Frederica
at 2008-06-13T07:26
at 2008-06-13T07:26

By Lauren
at 2008-06-17T17:42
at 2008-06-17T17:42

By Caitlin
at 2008-06-18T16:59
at 2008-06-18T16:59

By Michael
at 2008-06-22T19:53
at 2008-06-22T19:53

By Quanna
at 2008-06-25T00:44
at 2008-06-25T00:44

By Sarah
at 2008-06-29T19:22
at 2008-06-29T19:22

By Isla
at 2008-07-03T07:42
at 2008-07-03T07:42

By Yuri
at 2008-07-04T02:57
at 2008-07-04T02:57

By Necoo
at 2008-07-04T20:24
at 2008-07-04T20:24

By Ina
at 2008-07-09T14:55
at 2008-07-09T14:55

By Iris
at 2008-07-11T16:33
at 2008-07-11T16:33

By Skylar DavisLinda
at 2008-07-15T04:42
at 2008-07-15T04:42

By Belly
at 2008-07-15T15:39
at 2008-07-15T15:39

By Hedwig
at 2008-07-18T09:41
at 2008-07-18T09:41

By Caitlin
at 2008-07-22T18:54
at 2008-07-22T18:54

By Ethan
at 2008-07-27T13:28
at 2008-07-27T13:28

By Elvira
at 2008-07-27T19:05
at 2008-07-27T19:05

By Carol
at 2008-07-29T06:45
at 2008-07-29T06:45

By Elma
at 2008-08-03T03:50
at 2008-08-03T03:50

By Ingrid
at 2008-08-04T15:46
at 2008-08-04T15:46

By Carol
at 2008-08-05T04:17
at 2008-08-05T04:17

By Zora
at 2008-08-09T04:06
at 2008-08-09T04:06

By Charlie
at 2008-08-12T15:48
at 2008-08-12T15:48

By Vanessa
at 2008-08-14T13:29
at 2008-08-14T13:29

By Audriana
at 2008-08-15T07:41
at 2008-08-15T07:41

By Zora
at 2008-08-17T07:58
at 2008-08-17T07:58

By Donna
at 2008-08-18T05:18
at 2008-08-18T05:18

By Franklin
at 2008-08-22T01:03
at 2008-08-22T01:03

By Catherine
at 2008-08-23T21:06
at 2008-08-23T21:06

By Jack
at 2008-08-26T04:35
at 2008-08-26T04:35

By Isla
at 2008-08-28T19:34
at 2008-08-28T19:34

By Liam
at 2008-09-01T21:26
at 2008-09-01T21:26

By Freda
at 2008-09-04T09:23
at 2008-09-04T09:23

By Kristin
at 2008-09-04T22:34
at 2008-09-04T22:34

By Hazel
at 2008-09-08T01:07
at 2008-09-08T01:07

By Frederic
at 2008-09-12T07:24
at 2008-09-12T07:24

By Eden
at 2008-09-16T09:56
at 2008-09-16T09:56

By Lily
at 2008-09-17T23:12
at 2008-09-17T23:12

By Candice
at 2008-09-18T23:05
at 2008-09-18T23:05

By Belly
at 2008-09-23T06:05
at 2008-09-23T06:05

By Andrew
at 2008-09-24T19:06
at 2008-09-24T19:06

By Iris
at 2008-09-27T07:26
at 2008-09-27T07:26

By Olga
at 2008-10-01T02:38
at 2008-10-01T02:38

By Dora
at 2008-10-01T20:22
at 2008-10-01T20:22

By Odelette
at 2008-10-02T21:03
at 2008-10-02T21:03

By Faithe
at 2008-10-03T15:43
at 2008-10-03T15:43

By Hamiltion
at 2008-10-05T08:25
at 2008-10-05T08:25

By Emma
at 2008-10-08T20:24
at 2008-10-08T20:24

By Emma
at 2008-10-10T03:32
at 2008-10-10T03:32

By Blanche
at 2008-10-10T19:52
at 2008-10-10T19:52

By Erin
at 2008-10-13T00:41
at 2008-10-13T00:41

By Olga
at 2008-10-16T17:51
at 2008-10-16T17:51

By Steve
at 2008-10-19T10:55
at 2008-10-19T10:55

By Joseph
at 2008-10-19T17:30
at 2008-10-19T17:30

By Heather
at 2008-10-20T13:29
at 2008-10-20T13:29

By Lucy
at 2008-10-21T06:11
at 2008-10-21T06:11

By Victoria
at 2008-10-21T12:05
at 2008-10-21T12:05

By Connor
at 2008-10-23T19:37
at 2008-10-23T19:37

By Ida
at 2008-10-24T04:15
at 2008-10-24T04:15

By Erin
at 2008-10-27T12:48
at 2008-10-27T12:48

By Poppy
at 2008-10-28T20:35
at 2008-10-28T20:35

By Ingrid
at 2008-11-01T21:32
at 2008-11-01T21:32

By Jacob
at 2008-11-04T15:41
at 2008-11-04T15:41

By Yedda
at 2008-11-05T14:24
at 2008-11-05T14:24

By Hamiltion
at 2008-11-07T11:14
at 2008-11-07T11:14

By Mia
at 2008-11-11T03:14
at 2008-11-11T03:14

By Regina
at 2008-11-11T18:47
at 2008-11-11T18:47

By Quintina
at 2008-11-14T03:53
at 2008-11-14T03:53

By Quintina
at 2008-11-16T23:30
at 2008-11-16T23:30

By Emma
at 2008-11-18T20:48
at 2008-11-18T20:48

By Sandy
at 2008-11-22T15:45
at 2008-11-22T15:45

By Delia
at 2008-11-23T11:44
at 2008-11-23T11:44

By Edith
at 2008-11-24T03:11
at 2008-11-24T03:11

By Doris
at 2008-11-26T23:38
at 2008-11-26T23:38

By Hazel
at 2008-11-28T03:21
at 2008-11-28T03:21

By Ivy
at 2008-12-01T09:29
at 2008-12-01T09:29

By Kristin
at 2008-12-03T05:29
at 2008-12-03T05:29

By Hazel
at 2008-12-07T18:41
at 2008-12-07T18:41

By Susan
at 2008-12-12T11:15
at 2008-12-12T11:15

By Zora
at 2008-12-13T06:01
at 2008-12-13T06:01

By Jack
at 2008-12-16T04:37
at 2008-12-16T04:37

By Jack
at 2008-12-20T23:13
at 2008-12-20T23:13

By Skylar Davis
at 2008-12-21T15:31
at 2008-12-21T15:31

By Rae
at 2008-12-23T12:45
at 2008-12-23T12:45

By Daph Bay
at 2008-12-25T00:11
at 2008-12-25T00:11

By Michael
at 2008-12-28T07:26
at 2008-12-28T07:26

By Daniel
at 2008-12-31T09:35
at 2008-12-31T09:35

By Kama
at 2009-01-01T22:16
at 2009-01-01T22:16

By Kyle
at 2009-01-02T22:26
at 2009-01-02T22:26

By Vanessa
at 2009-01-07T12:30
at 2009-01-07T12:30

By Adele
at 2009-01-07T21:01
at 2009-01-07T21:01

By Anthony
at 2009-01-09T17:07
at 2009-01-09T17:07

By Annie
at 2009-01-14T12:33
at 2009-01-14T12:33

By Dorothy
at 2009-01-15T12:48
at 2009-01-15T12:48

By Edith
at 2009-01-17T03:39
at 2009-01-17T03:39

By David
at 2009-01-18T07:18
at 2009-01-18T07:18

By Odelette
at 2009-01-22T09:48
at 2009-01-22T09:48

By Lucy
at 2009-01-27T08:55
at 2009-01-27T08:55

By Xanthe
at 2009-01-30T16:44
at 2009-01-30T16:44
Related Posts
《1408》旅館恐怖片還能怎麼玩呢? (大雷)

By Irma
at 2007-08-03T21:40
at 2007-08-03T21:40
坐而言,不如起而行──《洞裡春光》

By Sarah
at 2007-08-02T12:47
at 2007-08-02T12:47
哪些人可以考慮去看《海之傳說─媽祖》?

By Valerie
at 2007-08-01T01:55
at 2007-08-01T01:55
《巴黎二日情》vs《巴黎初體驗》

By Rae
at 2007-07-31T04:01
at 2007-07-31T04:01
連體陰:一體兩面

By Frederica
at 2007-07-30T23:43
at 2007-07-30T23:43