KANO媚日？ 龍應台：它乾淨地講故事 - 電影
By Zora
at 2014-03-15T10:02
at 2014-03-15T10:02
Table of Contents
新聞網址：
http://udn.com/NEWS/ENTERTAINMENT/ENT3/8546678.shtml
【聯合報╱記者周美惠／台北報導】 2014.03.14 02:18 pm
電影「KANO」熱賣，也引發熱議。文化部長龍應台昨天說，創作者不必太在意外界看法，
重要的是要對得起自己心裡的那把尺。前文建會主委邱坤良則以「主題明確、敘事簡單、
缺乏驚奇」為名在臉書上貼文評論KANO。
龍應台昨天在立法院進行施政報告，藍綠立委皆探詢她對這部電影的看法。龍應台表示，
她看過KANO，這是一部「乾淨的電影」、「它不假裝」，很乾淨地講故事、把故事講得很
徹底。她說，過去一百年的歷史翻翻轉轉，還有很多「抽屜」裡的「小歷史」沒被打開，
裡頭藏著很多好的故事，等待發掘。
針對KANO片中「皇民化」意識型態的批評，龍應台說，創作者要對自己所做的知識功課負
責，要自問「對不對得起自己心裡的那把尺？」不必太在意外界的各種說法。她說，所謂
「史觀」從最左的到最右的、從最綠的到最藍的，都不一樣。創作者如果要滿足哪一個史
觀，就不要創作了。
邱坤良昨天也發表評論指出，KANO電影主場景是一九二九年至一九三一年。當時日本推行
「國語」（日語）已具成效，除了日本人，台灣球員彼此間講日語也很自然，但此時皇民
化運動尚未展開，台灣人講母語的情形仍然普遍。但整部影片「絕大部分的對話都是日語
」，「偶爾出現極少數台灣語言」（福佬話、客家話、原住民語），但都是零碎、無關緊
要的口白。
邱坤良另評論，KANO有大批嘉義鄉親繞著收音機，關注球賽進行的鏡頭，也出現八田與一
、嘉南大圳與嘉義噴水池的畫面，但「影片看不到嘉義，也看不到真正的嘉義人，」明顯
地暴露導演對當時台灣人生活觀察「很浮面」。
--
http://udn.com/NEWS/ENTERTAINMENT/ENT3/8546678.shtml
【聯合報╱記者周美惠／台北報導】 2014.03.14 02:18 pm
電影「KANO」熱賣，也引發熱議。文化部長龍應台昨天說，創作者不必太在意外界看法，
重要的是要對得起自己心裡的那把尺。前文建會主委邱坤良則以「主題明確、敘事簡單、
缺乏驚奇」為名在臉書上貼文評論KANO。
龍應台昨天在立法院進行施政報告，藍綠立委皆探詢她對這部電影的看法。龍應台表示，
她看過KANO，這是一部「乾淨的電影」、「它不假裝」，很乾淨地講故事、把故事講得很
徹底。她說，過去一百年的歷史翻翻轉轉，還有很多「抽屜」裡的「小歷史」沒被打開，
裡頭藏著很多好的故事，等待發掘。
針對KANO片中「皇民化」意識型態的批評，龍應台說，創作者要對自己所做的知識功課負
責，要自問「對不對得起自己心裡的那把尺？」不必太在意外界的各種說法。她說，所謂
「史觀」從最左的到最右的、從最綠的到最藍的，都不一樣。創作者如果要滿足哪一個史
觀，就不要創作了。
邱坤良昨天也發表評論指出，KANO電影主場景是一九二九年至一九三一年。當時日本推行
「國語」（日語）已具成效，除了日本人，台灣球員彼此間講日語也很自然，但此時皇民
化運動尚未展開，台灣人講母語的情形仍然普遍。但整部影片「絕大部分的對話都是日語
」，「偶爾出現極少數台灣語言」（福佬話、客家話、原住民語），但都是零碎、無關緊
要的口白。
邱坤良另評論，KANO有大批嘉義鄉親繞著收音機，關注球賽進行的鏡頭，也出現八田與一
、嘉南大圳與嘉義噴水池的畫面，但「影片看不到嘉義，也看不到真正的嘉義人，」明顯
地暴露導演對當時台灣人生活觀察「很浮面」。
--
Tags:
電影
All Comments
By Lily
at 2014-03-17T15:55
at 2014-03-17T15:55
By Jessica
at 2014-03-20T04:01
at 2014-03-20T04:01
By Jessica
at 2014-03-23T20:31
at 2014-03-23T20:31
By Audriana
at 2014-03-24T00:30
at 2014-03-24T00:30
By Rae
at 2014-03-26T20:28
at 2014-03-26T20:28
By Jacob
at 2014-03-27T04:24
at 2014-03-27T04:24
By Doris
at 2014-03-31T11:54
at 2014-03-31T11:54
By Jacob
at 2014-04-04T20:34
at 2014-04-04T20:34
By Callum
at 2014-04-07T03:53
at 2014-04-07T03:53
By Sandy
at 2014-04-11T15:35
at 2014-04-11T15:35
By Enid
at 2014-04-16T12:25
at 2014-04-16T12:25
By Belly
at 2014-04-18T04:41
at 2014-04-18T04:41
By Lily
at 2014-04-18T06:29
at 2014-04-18T06:29
By Faithe
at 2014-04-21T15:12
at 2014-04-21T15:12
By Lily
at 2014-04-26T12:23
at 2014-04-26T12:23
By Dora
at 2014-04-30T22:36
at 2014-04-30T22:36
By Dora
at 2014-05-03T01:29
at 2014-05-03T01:29
By Ivy
at 2014-05-03T16:27
at 2014-05-03T16:27
By Belly
at 2014-05-07T22:04
at 2014-05-07T22:04
By Daniel
at 2014-05-09T22:57
at 2014-05-09T22:57
By Emma
at 2014-05-12T17:18
at 2014-05-12T17:18
By Blanche
at 2014-05-15T21:47
at 2014-05-15T21:47
By John
at 2014-05-16T08:00
at 2014-05-16T08:00
By Noah
at 2014-05-17T19:07
at 2014-05-17T19:07
By Linda
at 2014-05-18T16:32
at 2014-05-18T16:32
By Michael
at 2014-05-23T03:03
at 2014-05-23T03:03
By Zanna
at 2014-05-24T19:03
at 2014-05-24T19:03
By Jessica
at 2014-05-29T05:39
at 2014-05-29T05:39
By Heather
at 2014-06-01T17:27
at 2014-06-01T17:27
By Kyle
at 2014-06-06T05:21
at 2014-06-06T05:21
By Gilbert
at 2014-06-09T23:52
at 2014-06-09T23:52
By Charlotte
at 2014-06-14T18:35
at 2014-06-14T18:35
By Erin
at 2014-06-15T03:09
at 2014-06-15T03:09
By Joe
at 2014-06-17T05:26
at 2014-06-17T05:26
By Kumar
at 2014-06-21T13:57
at 2014-06-21T13:57
By Christine
at 2014-06-24T04:31
at 2014-06-24T04:31
By Hamiltion
at 2014-06-27T22:55
at 2014-06-27T22:55
By Zenobia
at 2014-06-28T10:05
at 2014-06-28T10:05
By Puput
at 2014-06-30T05:23
at 2014-06-30T05:23
By Iris
at 2014-07-03T12:31
at 2014-07-03T12:31
By Poppy
at 2014-07-05T08:27
at 2014-07-05T08:27
By Bennie
at 2014-07-07T08:42
at 2014-07-07T08:42
By Puput
at 2014-07-08T02:06
at 2014-07-08T02:06
By Ethan
at 2014-07-08T03:43
at 2014-07-08T03:43
By Jacob
at 2014-07-08T10:35
at 2014-07-08T10:35
By Eartha
at 2014-07-08T14:05
at 2014-07-08T14:05
By Emily
at 2014-07-09T18:37
at 2014-07-09T18:37
By Carolina Franco
at 2014-07-10T02:04
at 2014-07-10T02:04
By William
at 2014-07-14T14:01
at 2014-07-14T14:01
By Todd Johnson
at 2014-07-19T06:16
at 2014-07-19T06:16
By Erin
at 2014-07-20T07:48
at 2014-07-20T07:48
By Quanna
at 2014-07-22T04:41
at 2014-07-22T04:41
By Thomas
at 2014-07-25T18:24
at 2014-07-25T18:24
By Wallis
at 2014-07-30T11:47
at 2014-07-30T11:47
By Wallis
at 2014-07-31T23:36
at 2014-07-31T23:36
By Dinah
at 2014-08-03T05:20
at 2014-08-03T05:20
By Suhail Hany
at 2014-08-03T21:29
at 2014-08-03T21:29
By Valerie
at 2014-08-07T00:34
at 2014-08-07T00:34
By Gilbert
at 2014-08-10T02:47
at 2014-08-10T02:47
By Olga
at 2014-08-14T12:51
at 2014-08-14T12:51
By Rae
at 2014-08-14T15:40
at 2014-08-14T15:40
By Thomas
at 2014-08-19T14:17
at 2014-08-19T14:17
By Isabella
at 2014-08-20T08:54
at 2014-08-20T08:54
By Irma
at 2014-08-23T06:49
at 2014-08-23T06:49
By Dora
at 2014-08-26T15:30
at 2014-08-26T15:30
By Oliver
at 2014-08-29T10:58
at 2014-08-29T10:58
By Susan
at 2014-08-30T22:08
at 2014-08-30T22:08
By Hamiltion
at 2014-09-03T02:17
at 2014-09-03T02:17
By Kristin
at 2014-09-05T01:18
at 2014-09-05T01:18
By Linda
at 2014-09-07T17:46
at 2014-09-07T17:46
By Ivy
at 2014-09-11T22:17
at 2014-09-11T22:17
By Kristin
at 2014-09-13T22:30
at 2014-09-13T22:30
By Hedy
at 2014-09-17T16:05
at 2014-09-17T16:05
By Zora
at 2014-09-22T00:45
at 2014-09-22T00:45
By Daniel
at 2014-09-25T16:13
at 2014-09-25T16:13
By Ula
at 2014-09-30T09:38
at 2014-09-30T09:38
By Andy
at 2014-10-03T06:44
at 2014-10-03T06:44
By Delia
at 2014-10-04T06:49
at 2014-10-04T06:49
By Kumar
at 2014-10-07T13:39
at 2014-10-07T13:39
By Tom
at 2014-10-10T14:35
at 2014-10-10T14:35
By Michael
at 2014-10-11T00:18
at 2014-10-11T00:18
By Olivia
at 2014-10-12T04:12
at 2014-10-12T04:12
By Mary
at 2014-10-14T10:51
at 2014-10-14T10:51
By Joe
at 2014-10-18T20:31
at 2014-10-18T20:31
By Jake
at 2014-10-22T15:52
at 2014-10-22T15:52
By Mary
at 2014-10-26T15:27
at 2014-10-26T15:27
By Lydia
at 2014-10-27T04:39
at 2014-10-27T04:39
By Isla
at 2014-10-31T15:16
at 2014-10-31T15:16
By Erin
at 2014-11-05T08:20
at 2014-11-05T08:20
By Irma
at 2014-11-06T08:52
at 2014-11-06T08:52
By Lauren
at 2014-11-08T21:45
at 2014-11-08T21:45
By Heather
at 2014-11-13T02:30
at 2014-11-13T02:30
By Annie
at 2014-11-14T20:51
at 2014-11-14T20:51
By Emma
at 2014-11-16T19:21
at 2014-11-16T19:21
By Michael
at 2014-11-21T14:16
at 2014-11-21T14:16
By Connor
at 2014-11-24T20:28
at 2014-11-24T20:28
By Hedy
at 2014-11-27T16:51
at 2014-11-27T16:51
By Eden
at 2014-11-28T03:43
at 2014-11-28T03:43
By Hedy
at 2014-12-03T02:06
at 2014-12-03T02:06
By Todd Johnson
at 2014-12-06T19:52
at 2014-12-06T19:52
By Ophelia
at 2014-12-09T03:26
at 2014-12-09T03:26
By Elvira
at 2014-12-13T05:25
at 2014-12-13T05:25
By Todd Johnson
at 2014-12-16T02:17
at 2014-12-16T02:17
By Megan
at 2014-12-18T13:37
at 2014-12-18T13:37
By Mason
at 2014-12-20T20:08
at 2014-12-20T20:08
By Hedwig
at 2014-12-25T03:07
at 2014-12-25T03:07
By William
at 2014-12-25T05:12
at 2014-12-25T05:12
By Emily
at 2014-12-25T09:42
at 2014-12-25T09:42
By Emily
at 2014-12-26T08:03
at 2014-12-26T08:03
By Eartha
at 2014-12-31T05:22
at 2014-12-31T05:22
By Queena
at 2015-01-01T22:22
at 2015-01-01T22:22
By Megan
at 2015-01-02T12:47
at 2015-01-02T12:47
By Thomas
at 2015-01-03T17:41
at 2015-01-03T17:41
By Daph Bay
at 2015-01-06T19:34
at 2015-01-06T19:34
By Wallis
at 2015-01-08T22:32
at 2015-01-08T22:32
By Bethany
at 2015-01-13T03:07
at 2015-01-13T03:07
By Olivia
at 2015-01-17T02:14
at 2015-01-17T02:14
By Ivy
at 2015-01-21T07:09
at 2015-01-21T07:09
By Franklin
at 2015-01-21T21:57
at 2015-01-21T21:57
By Kyle
at 2015-01-22T12:18
at 2015-01-22T12:18
By Isabella
at 2015-01-25T16:35
at 2015-01-25T16:35
By Wallis
at 2015-01-28T22:35
at 2015-01-28T22:35
By Isla
at 2015-01-30T04:40
at 2015-01-30T04:40
By Candice
at 2015-02-02T18:35
at 2015-02-02T18:35
By Kumar
at 2015-02-05T07:57
at 2015-02-05T07:57
By Heather
at 2015-02-09T09:41
at 2015-02-09T09:41
By Robert
at 2015-02-10T05:39
at 2015-02-10T05:39
By Ivy
at 2015-02-13T23:20
at 2015-02-13T23:20
By Bennie
at 2015-02-18T23:09
at 2015-02-18T23:09
By Ivy
at 2015-02-20T20:22
at 2015-02-20T20:22
By Sandy
at 2015-02-20T23:47
at 2015-02-20T23:47
By Sandy
at 2015-02-25T22:07
at 2015-02-25T22:07
By Caroline
at 2015-02-27T04:12
at 2015-02-27T04:12
By Robert
at 2015-03-03T16:58
at 2015-03-03T16:58
By Brianna
at 2015-03-06T04:25
at 2015-03-06T04:25
By Lauren
at 2015-03-08T06:33
at 2015-03-08T06:33
By Doris
at 2015-03-09T00:40
at 2015-03-09T00:40
By Elvira
at 2015-03-12T00:14
at 2015-03-12T00:14
By Rachel
at 2015-03-13T05:38
at 2015-03-13T05:38
By Gary
at 2015-03-14T15:29
at 2015-03-14T15:29
By Agnes
at 2015-03-16T12:34
at 2015-03-16T12:34
By George
at 2015-03-19T16:18
at 2015-03-19T16:18
By Zanna
at 2015-03-20T22:14
at 2015-03-20T22:14
By Faithe
at 2015-03-24T00:10
at 2015-03-24T00:10
By Jake
at 2015-03-27T01:45
at 2015-03-27T01:45
By Skylar Davis
at 2015-03-31T03:05
at 2015-03-31T03:05
By Elma
at 2015-03-31T12:31
at 2015-03-31T12:31
By Oscar
at 2015-04-01T01:30
at 2015-04-01T01:30
By Hedda
at 2015-04-02T12:47
at 2015-04-02T12:47
By George
at 2015-04-02T19:30
at 2015-04-02T19:30
By Steve
at 2015-04-04T20:33
at 2015-04-04T20:33
By Agatha
at 2015-04-09T08:48
at 2015-04-09T08:48
By Regina
at 2015-04-14T07:41
at 2015-04-14T07:41
By Anonymous
at 2015-04-18T13:50
at 2015-04-18T13:50
By Ina
at 2015-04-18T18:16
at 2015-04-18T18:16
By Emma
at 2015-04-19T16:31
at 2015-04-19T16:31
By Dorothy
at 2015-04-21T10:58
at 2015-04-21T10:58
By Necoo
at 2015-04-26T03:19
at 2015-04-26T03:19
By Ethan
at 2015-04-27T16:58
at 2015-04-27T16:58
By Caitlin
at 2015-04-29T13:11
at 2015-04-29T13:11
By Mary
at 2015-05-02T02:27
at 2015-05-02T02:27
By Ursula
at 2015-05-02T18:16
at 2015-05-02T18:16
By Anthony
at 2015-05-03T13:28
at 2015-05-03T13:28
By Cara
at 2015-05-05T02:11
at 2015-05-05T02:11
By Odelette
at 2015-05-08T03:31
at 2015-05-08T03:31
By Sarah
at 2015-05-08T20:05
at 2015-05-08T20:05
By Queena
at 2015-05-11T18:00
at 2015-05-11T18:00
By Agatha
at 2015-05-13T18:44
at 2015-05-13T18:44
By Andrew
at 2015-05-17T06:18
at 2015-05-17T06:18
By Hedy
at 2015-05-17T10:05
at 2015-05-17T10:05
By Gilbert
at 2015-05-20T13:10
at 2015-05-20T13:10
By Sarah
at 2015-05-22T05:09
at 2015-05-22T05:09
By Agatha
at 2015-05-24T17:18
at 2015-05-24T17:18
By Linda
at 2015-05-26T14:35
at 2015-05-26T14:35
By Mia
at 2015-05-28T02:06
at 2015-05-28T02:06
By Olga
at 2015-05-29T16:33
at 2015-05-29T16:33
By Zora
at 2015-05-30T23:09
at 2015-05-30T23:09
By Steve
at 2015-05-31T22:44
at 2015-05-31T22:44
By Blanche
at 2015-06-02T13:42
at 2015-06-02T13:42
By James
at 2015-06-05T18:57
at 2015-06-05T18:57
By Robert
at 2015-06-06T06:42
at 2015-06-06T06:42
By Candice
at 2015-06-08T16:50
at 2015-06-08T16:50
By Michael
at 2015-06-08T22:29
at 2015-06-08T22:29
By Lauren
at 2015-06-13T15:37
at 2015-06-13T15:37
By Aaliyah
at 2015-06-15T00:22
at 2015-06-15T00:22
By Isla
at 2015-06-16T10:28
at 2015-06-16T10:28
By Sandy
at 2015-06-19T21:32
at 2015-06-19T21:32
By Barb Cronin
at 2015-06-23T23:54
at 2015-06-23T23:54
By Kristin
at 2015-06-25T03:40
at 2015-06-25T03:40
By Barb Cronin
at 2015-06-30T00:02
at 2015-06-30T00:02
By Zenobia
at 2015-07-04T10:51
at 2015-07-04T10:51
By Brianna
at 2015-07-06T20:32
at 2015-07-06T20:32
By Robert
at 2015-07-08T13:34
at 2015-07-08T13:34
By Mia
at 2015-07-11T00:38
at 2015-07-11T00:38
By Belly
at 2015-07-14T22:01
at 2015-07-14T22:01
By Queena
at 2015-07-17T10:19
at 2015-07-17T10:19
By Andy
at 2015-07-19T21:52
at 2015-07-19T21:52
By Mary
at 2015-07-22T15:16
at 2015-07-22T15:16
By Rosalind
at 2015-07-24T18:58
at 2015-07-24T18:58
By Rachel
at 2015-07-26T16:08
at 2015-07-26T16:08
By Dora
at 2015-07-28T16:35
at 2015-07-28T16:35
By Bennie
at 2015-08-02T07:30
at 2015-08-02T07:30
By Suhail Hany
at 2015-08-02T12:54
at 2015-08-02T12:54
By Cara
at 2015-08-02T15:59
at 2015-08-02T15:59
By Donna
at 2015-08-06T07:22
at 2015-08-06T07:22
By Skylar Davis
at 2015-08-10T08:22
at 2015-08-10T08:22
By Linda
at 2015-08-11T06:34
at 2015-08-11T06:34
By Suhail Hany
at 2015-08-15T12:34
at 2015-08-15T12:34
By Franklin
at 2015-08-20T05:18
at 2015-08-20T05:18
By Necoo
at 2015-08-23T21:20
at 2015-08-23T21:20
By Michael
at 2015-08-24T02:05
at 2015-08-24T02:05
By Todd Johnson
at 2015-08-27T20:46
at 2015-08-27T20:46
By Audriana
at 2015-08-31T13:04
at 2015-08-31T13:04
By Madame
at 2015-09-04T12:28
at 2015-09-04T12:28
Related Posts
《大稻埕》《鐵獅》賣大陸撈回本
By Puput
at 2014-03-15T08:21
at 2014-03-15T08:21
《KANO》讓阿公被三振 孫女不介意
By Susan
at 2014-03-15T08:06
at 2014-03-15T08:06
讓心情好不用腦袋的片子
By Callum
at 2014-03-15T07:49
at 2014-03-15T07:49
賽德克巴萊證明魏德聖並不媚日!
By Mason
at 2014-03-15T07:26
at 2014-03-15T07:26
賽德克巴萊證明魏德聖並不媚日!
By Tom
at 2014-03-15T07:03
at 2014-03-15T07:03