Re: AI TOP 9結果(大雷) ......S....H....E...E...T - 實境秀

※ 引述《graff (graff)》之銘言：
: S......H.....E.....E....T
: 我必須說
: 我真的很不爽
: 走的居然是MANDISA
: 連三個評審全場觀眾都是意外的表情
: 我必須說
: 他真的很會唱
: 是因為外型嗎??
: 美國人怎麼會不喜歡他

說穿了還是跟信仰、種族歧視還有她的體型有關係

體型和種族歧視的問題本來就存在，所以就不提
倒是信仰的部分可能是使她提早中箭落馬的原因。

Mandisa 在 American Idol 的網站上
親筆寫著 Beth Moore 這位知名的「反同志」名人是她的偶像
她認為 Moore "inspires me to live more like Jesus, and I want to do the same."
American Idol 方面則不對此作任何評論。

http://www.advocate.com/news_detail_ektid28426.asp

加上在上週，Mandisa 選唱了流行福音團體 Mary Mary 的歌曲 Shackles (Praise You)
在演唱前 Mandisa 說的這段導言：

This song goes out to everybody that wants to be free. Your addiction,
lifestyle, or situation may be big, but God is bigger.

其中的 "lifestyle" 是否是指「同志」，引發了一連串的爭論。

當然 Mandisa 隨後當然是澄清了這個錯誤的解讀。
不過一般認為，這多少讓她的支持者族群產生了變化，尤其是支持她的同志族群。
加上先前她被認為總是在安全領域內，也可能讓她的支持者掉以輕心。

不過，她淘汰後接受 The Advocate 訪問時
她說絕不會在不甚了解的情況下對同志的議題或任何人作評論
但基於她的個人信念，她不會在同志的場合表演，同時也不「提倡」同性戀。

http://www.advocate.com/exclusive_detail_ektid29157.asp

hmm...不過這種能唱的 Diva 其實大都頗受同志們的歡迎，這是不爭的事實 =.=
這樣的回答感覺真的不夠「圓滑」和聰明哪 =.=

另外這幾天
有當晚在現場的觀眾指出當晚的 Result Show 有發生一點小插曲。

不曉得有沒有人發現
在 Ryan 宣布 Mandisa 被淘汰後
鏡頭陸續帶到家屬、觀眾、評審和參賽者
他們的表情及觀眾的反應不太對勁？

因為當時有幾個女孩當場對 Mandisa 喊出了帶有歧視意味的攻擊話語。

如果手邊有這集影像檔的話，在17分16秒左右，仔細聽或許可以隱約聽到
只是被觀眾的噓聲和節目背景音樂給蓋過去了
但看當時觀眾的反應，以及 Katharine 和 Paris 的表情
還是可以感覺得出來有些不對勁。

Disturbing news about Mandisa and her elimination, Found this on idolonfox

There was a thread on here from someone who was there, but I cant find it
now. This is the original post from the person who was there. He posted
several times to that thread and he sounded totally credible to me. I feel
totally embarassed and disgusted by those girls.

Post from Goldberg

Hey guys, I couldn't believe what happened the other night..I just got back
today from California (Visiting family while they were on spring break) and
we went to the results show because they had been on the waiting list since
the beginning of last season. I just realized that some of you figured
something was edited. Well I can tell you what happened...there were a group
of 3 or 4 girls, by the looks they were white and hispanic teenagers...
anyway, when Ryan announced that Mandisa was gone, they jumped up and were
throwing their hands up yelling "Bye Bye N___er" and "Go Home N___a"..infact
you can hear the last time it was said like some of you have pointed out...
it was total shock in that room, guys..those girls were jerked out of that
room faster than you could blink, but it had all already been said and had
it's affect..needless to say, the mood of the whole place sunk and it never
did regain the excitement...we were all left with sick feelings in our
stomachs..there were several people that could be seen that had been crying,
whether from anger or frustration..it was sad..We Love You Mandisa!

End of Goldber's post

I can see why Fox bleeped it out. In another post he also said the audience
was quick to point out the girls to security so they could be removed so
quickly.

http://idolforums.com/index.php?showtopic=416269&st=0



--