Tim Gunn的訪問 (有對PR2 Final的看法) - 實境秀

Selena avatar
By Selena
at 2006-08-09T17:55

Table of Contents


http://urlsnip.com/793391 (全文很長, 少部份節錄於下)
*****有些對PR 3參賽者的雷*******


Tim 針對冠軍選出過程的說法:

“......I am in absolute agreement. Can I tell you what happened there, with the
[final] runway judgment?”

“I was sitting with the Bravo legal department. We were listening to the
dialogue, and can I just tell you, Debra Messing was terrific – boy, does
she know clothes and how to talk about them. So we had Debra, Nina, Michael
and Heidi. This runway deliberation went on for two hours. I was sitting with
the legal department, and we were whispering, going ‘It’s Daniel, it’s
Santino, it’s Daniel, it’s Santino.’

“About an hour and 40 minutes into this, Nina goes into this rhapsodic
soliloquy about Chloe and her collection, and throws into it all of her
successes during [the season], and how everything’s been memorable around.
It was going to Daniel, and [Nina] turned everybody around to Chloe. It was
the most remarkable thing I’ve ever seen.

“The legal people turn to me, kind of with incredulity and say, ‘It’s
Chloe?’ And I said, ‘I trust nothing until it comes out of Heidi’s mouth.’
And it did! And I couldn’t believe it. I simply couldn’t believe it.

“I will tell you, and this goes to the integrity of the show, the producers
and Bravo were in a state. And Frances Berwick, executive vice president of
Bravo, could conceivably have stopped it, but she said, ‘It’s their
decision.’ I just was … I kept saying, ‘How are you going to explain this
to the audience? Anybody looking at that is going to think that’s crazy!’”


對於Santino 衣服不合身的解釋:

“.......There were two big things about Santino – one was the fit of his clothes
[in the final collections], and I wanted to say, ‘Give the guy a break.’ He
came to New York with everything beautifully finished, but the runway models
were extremely late. Most did not show up until Thursday – the runway show
was Friday. Our call time was 5:30 a.m. He had to fit 10 girls on Thursday,
plus we had the 13th look [he had to create]. I felt really bad for him.


Tim對於Chloe作品的看法:

“......The kind of reaction I gave to Daniel, and I know people were mad at me
about that – I gave Chloe a worse reaction, but of course they edited that
out, because she won. I said to Chloe, ‘Where’s the couch and the ottoman?
You’re a sportswear designer, where did this come from?’”

訪問者: I know, that’s the thing. She did a lot of very fresh, clean, young things
for the show – and then it was like, where did these “Dynasty” outfits
come from?

“Those words were even said by me! ‘Where are Linda Evans and Joan Collins?
’ I didn’t know what to say. Then we got into a big argument, I don’t
remember if this was on the show, over what Grace would wear. Grace was her
signature model and would wear her last look. I said, ‘Look, I’m trying to
help you. Get her out of that couch!’”



※ 編輯: radha 來自: 219.84.126.195 (08/09 18:10)
WinonaBecks:DV真的如Tim說的My darling little Dan has become a 08/09 19:02
WinonaBecks:terrible diva(?)之前看這篇一直很在意這點...@@a 08/09 19:03
fdav:原來是Nina支持Chloe的呀...這篇打破電視上所呈現的印象XDDDD 08/09 19:03
FeatherBaby:看了這篇後 感覺只有...WOW! 08/09 19:27
momo7426:Tim爆了很多料呀...真精彩...... 08/09 19:49
Rdkl1e9z:如果Santino的Models能早到一點讓他修改fit的問題~也許 08/09 19:54
Rdkl1e9z:情況會改觀~譬如拿到第二名之類的 08/09 19:56
themask:我還是認為Santino跟Chole的Collection平分秋色 08/09 19:59
ariachiang:基本上我認為的F2應該是DV跟SANTINO 08/09 20:12
ariachiang:想到TIM居然舉出經典肥皂劇朝代...沒錯就是那種感覺 08/09 20:20
ariachiang:就是那種我姑姑以前看到要死要活的那種骨董影集裡面的 08/09 20:21
ariachiang:服裝的STYLE就是CHLOE在final裡面設計出來的那種 08/09 20:21
Bocaj:不過我還是不能理解為什麼final的評審會請Debra Messing!? 08/09 20:38
Bocaj:果然是剪接是不能盡信啊...我還以為MK才是決策關鍵XD 08/09 20:38
Bocaj:而且我一直不太能接受評審說Santino沒創意... 08/09 20:40
Dolce:至少Debra Messing比第一季的客席評審好多了... 08/09 21:00
kizuna1019:我想Nina應該是主導政策性意見,讓Chole贏應該是節目 08/09 21:06
kizuna1019:政策..就像S1我一直以為Kara會贏 >"<////~~~ 08/09 21:07
panasia:Debra Messing的觀點很不錯啊 08/09 22:37
panasia:感覺節目製作本身也不大看好Chloe...不過Tim還真敢說 08/09 22:37
panasia:還有實境節目的剪接真的很容易左右觀眾的觀點..... 08/09 22:38
helencherry:英文不好看不懂@@ 08/09 22:51
fluffy22:在看這一篇之前 我老是對Nina印象不好 也說不出為什麼 08/09 23:08
fluffy22:現在終於可以解釋了 反而MK的講評比較容易讓人信服 08/09 23:09
playroot:如果Santino有時間修改衣服就好了:( 08/09 23:20
paulyung:Kara的鞋子有犯規,所以鞋子包包全部不記分,光是看這點 08/11 09:59
paulyung:Kara就出局。DV相較之下太弱了,他還沒辦法整合整個系列 08/11 10:00
paulyung:,不過他還很年輕,最看好他的未來。 08/11 10:02
mhhe:個人不認為是政策給他嬴 若是政策的話 dv其中一個挑戰應該 08/14 22:24
mhhe:給andrae嬴 然後dv得冠軍 這樣結果才不會那麼理所當然 08/14 22:25


All Comments

Rachel avatar
By Rachel
at 2006-08-11T18:27
DV真的如Tim說的My darling little Dan has become a
Tom avatar
By Tom
at 2006-08-16T16:01
terrible diva(?)之前看這篇一直很在意這點...@@a
Adele avatar
By Adele
at 2006-08-20T03:26
原來是Nina支持Chloe的呀...這篇打破電視上所呈現的印象XDDDD
Erin avatar
By Erin
at 2006-08-21T12:49
看了這篇後 感覺只有...WOW!
Tom avatar
By Tom
at 2006-08-26T12:23
Tim爆了很多料呀...真精彩......
Anonymous avatar
By Anonymous
at 2006-08-30T16:30
如果Santino的Models能早到一點讓他修改fit的問題~也許
Faithe avatar
By Faithe
at 2006-09-04T00:59
情況會改觀~譬如拿到第二名之類的
Zanna avatar
By Zanna
at 2006-09-08T06:28
我還是認為Santino跟Chole的Collection平分秋色
Mason avatar
By Mason
at 2006-09-11T13:12
基本上我認為的F2應該是DV跟SANTINO
Ina avatar
By Ina
at 2006-09-15T12:45
想到TIM居然舉出經典肥皂劇朝代...沒錯就是那種感覺
Barb Cronin avatar
By Barb Cronin
at 2006-09-18T10:18
就是那種我姑姑以前看到要死要活的那種骨董影集裡面的
服裝的STYLE就是CHLOE在final裡面設計出來的那種
Rebecca avatar
By Rebecca
at 2006-09-20T15:49
不過我還是不能理解為什麼final的評審會請Debra Messing!?
果然是剪接是不能盡信啊...我還以為MK才是決策關鍵XD
Lauren avatar
By Lauren
at 2006-09-23T15:20
而且我一直不太能接受評審說Santino沒創意...
Jacky avatar
By Jacky
at 2006-09-28T13:23
至少Debra Messing比第一季的客席評審好多了...
Kyle avatar
By Kyle
at 2006-09-29T06:11
我想Nina應該是主導政策性意見,讓Chole贏應該是節目
Gilbert avatar
By Gilbert
at 2006-10-02T19:50
政策..就像S1我一直以為Kara會贏 >"<////~~~
Tristan Cohan avatar
By Tristan Cohan
at 2006-10-04T11:51
Debra Messing的觀點很不錯啊
感覺節目製作本身也不大看好Chloe...不過Tim還真敢說
Poppy avatar
By Poppy
at 2006-10-05T19:03
還有實境節目的剪接真的很容易左右觀眾的觀點.....
Zenobia avatar
By Zenobia
at 2006-10-09T15:03
英文不好看不懂@@
Adele avatar
By Adele
at 2006-10-13T10:35
在看這一篇之前 我老是對Nina印象不好 也說不出為什麼
Connor avatar
By Connor
at 2006-10-16T23:46
現在終於可以解釋了 反而MK的講評比較容易讓人信服
Lucy avatar
By Lucy
at 2006-10-17T13:57
如果Santino有時間修改衣服就好了:(
Ethan avatar
By Ethan
at 2006-10-19T01:41
Kara的鞋子有犯規,所以鞋子包包全部不記分,光是看這點
Rae avatar
By Rae
at 2006-10-22T06:35
Kara就出局。DV相較之下太弱了,他還沒辦法整合整個系列
Selena avatar
By Selena
at 2006-10-24T21:15
,不過他還很年輕,最看好他的未來。
Jack avatar
By Jack
at 2006-10-25T10:22
個人不認為是政策給他嬴 若是政策的話 dv其中一個挑戰應該
Carolina Franco avatar
By Carolina Franco
at 2006-10-27T15:44
給andrae嬴 然後dv得冠軍 這樣結果才不會那麼理所當然

PR S2 決賽

Donna avatar
By Donna
at 2006-08-09T16:50
今天中國時報的生活副刊有報導克羅伊得獎的消息 上面放得照片是她的秀的第一件衣服 看來克羅伊是真的成名的感覺 但是報導上寫他是從泰國來的 應該改為寮國吧 - ...

PR S2 決賽

Queena avatar
By Queena
at 2006-08-09T12:01
稍微離題一下 雖然評審不見得有把個性及非服裝的能力部份納入考量 但比較起來,我個人覺得Chloe真的小勝一些 以個性來說,我覺得Santino的抗壓性顯然有點低 (像是之前挑戰的幾次自暴自棄來看,還有他的好勝心) 另外,再加上他的嘴,和他接觸過的人對他的評價要不大好就是大壞 雖然設計工作本身可以單打獨鬥,看 ...

PR S2 決賽

Adele avatar
By Adele
at 2006-08-09T10:46
: 不過我覺得SANTINO的衣服雖然沒有了那些誇裝的創意 : 但我還是覺得很漂亮說@@ : 飄飄的好 認同+1 只能說我跟評審的眼光差太多了點 (以下是我的心得,按出場順序) DV的衣服看完我只有是為banana republic設計的感覺 很OL阿,也蠻保守的~沒有之前的蘭花裝那麼令人驚艷 布料質感和顏 ...

PR S2 決賽

Rae avatar
By Rae
at 2006-08-09T09:42
: 先前就因為很喜歡他的個性而一直最希望他拿冠軍~ : 這次他所設計的衣服真的很精緻 : 我最喜歡的就是褲裝的那套,實在是太好看了! 但是我有不同意見,因為看來看去我並不覺得她的服裝真的漂亮 只是在精緻度上比較明顯 (例如說剪裁跟車縫處) 尤其是那幾件閃亮亮的連背心洋裝 我個人覺得有點可怕,不過倒是挺像中南半 ...

Genevieve avatar
By Genevieve
at 2006-08-09T09:28
++開場前++ Daniel和Chloe的感情好像不錯 出門前還會一起聊聊天  有趣的是Daniel的model都在幫他縫衣服 噗 ++走秀++ **Daniel 開場介紹時講得不錯 不虧是總是很會說話的人~ --有兩件衣服肩線怪怪的 (其中一件是當初給Tim看的那件...東方風味的花紋) ...