滿城盡帶黃金甲,金甲包屎欠人罵 - 電影

By Rosalind
at 2007-01-03T21:27
at 2007-01-03T21:27
Table of Contents
每逢小學的美術課,小朋友總會拿著白色的塑膠盤,擠出帶點硬塊的雄獅水彩,依
想像將顏料攪和融合,期望能調配出最美麗的顏色;小朋友通常不懂色彩學,這東
西連老師都未必有學,所以調出來的顏色,不是很奇怪,就是很難看。
其中,最難看的顏色,就是不分三七二十一、將所有顏料擠在一起,簡直就是和堆
肥似地調出來的準大便色,稱其為準,是因為那顏色未必完全等同於大便色,然而
,對那團黏糊不堪的玩意兒來說,除了大便,還會有更好的形容嗎?
這就是【滿城盡帶黃金甲】給我的第一印象。
視覺上,盡是土財主式的粗豔、暴發戶式的俗庸,這病症在【英雄】與【十面埋伏
】已四處可見,然而其劇情就算空洞,影像起碼還頗瑰麗平衡,反觀本片的無限金
光,過度的網膜轟炸、視覺疲乏,像是葷食過多的饗宴,逼人味蕾昏麻。
聽覺上,滿是不合時宜的刺耳人聲,好像不來點人聲,電影就有失莊嚴而無神,那
不西不中的基調催生出一頭噪音怪獸,讓人視覺疲軟之餘,聽覺還被重複凌遲,難
怪有小道消息指出,公安部門已相中此曲,拷打訓問無不合適。
情節上,全是典型的激昂血淚,從【英雄】到【夜宴】,中國古裝始終如一的恩怨
情仇果真是絲毫未斷,張藝謀號稱的最終古裝巨作更是狗血盡灑、死命芭樂,從鬩
牆到亂倫,從殺妻到弒父,最後再來個虐子,真是台灣龍捲風、北京一起瘋。
所以,從視覺到聽覺,從聽覺到情節,從上到下,由內到外,本片真是時時有黃金
、處處有大便,大便可以來自重金,重金能讓大便看起來很高級,然而,大便就是
大便,不會因為灑上金粉、撲上花瓣後就變成真金。
其實,渴望華麗不是病、硬充莊嚴沒關係,至於龍捲風,中外王室本來就愛得要命
,問題是張大導老大不學好,寫了兩齣鬧劇被批爆、死到臨頭還覺悟不了,【夜宴
】的蠢斃遊戲才剛平息,張大導就迫不及待地為中國古裝片打出了最後一擊。
託他的福,原已奄奄一息的中國古裝片,如今終於壽終正寢、徹底死透,以後不論
誰想走這條老路,都不過是趕屍上路。
這種作品,如果再傳票房捷報、再來好評連場,豈不是昭告天下:身有黃金甲,天
塌都不怕,劇本不用好,有錢屌最大?搞到如此,才是豈有此理、人神共憤,所以
,真是不罵不行,不批無理!
最後,不斷地向西方拋媚眼的張藝謀,真的該學西方的吉伯遜老伯,人家粗裡粗氣
、看來缺乏導演造詣,可是【英雄本色】同樣是權謀、戰爭、龍捲風,成果卻平實
順暢、惹人感動,雖然服裝扮相骯髒,跟金甲裡面包大便一比還是很強!
而吉伯遜老伯原本還只是個動作演員呢!由此,原本專擅精緻小品的張大導,怎能
不去一趟勞改營,好好檢討檢討?
出處:http://www.wretch.cc/blog/woosean&article_id=5649543
--
文字是迷途者在黑森林中唯一的慰藉。
我的網誌:http://www.wretch.cc/blog/woosean
批兔個人板:SeanW
--
想像將顏料攪和融合,期望能調配出最美麗的顏色;小朋友通常不懂色彩學,這東
西連老師都未必有學,所以調出來的顏色,不是很奇怪,就是很難看。
其中,最難看的顏色,就是不分三七二十一、將所有顏料擠在一起,簡直就是和堆
肥似地調出來的準大便色,稱其為準,是因為那顏色未必完全等同於大便色,然而
,對那團黏糊不堪的玩意兒來說,除了大便,還會有更好的形容嗎?
這就是【滿城盡帶黃金甲】給我的第一印象。
視覺上,盡是土財主式的粗豔、暴發戶式的俗庸,這病症在【英雄】與【十面埋伏
】已四處可見,然而其劇情就算空洞,影像起碼還頗瑰麗平衡,反觀本片的無限金
光,過度的網膜轟炸、視覺疲乏,像是葷食過多的饗宴,逼人味蕾昏麻。
聽覺上,滿是不合時宜的刺耳人聲,好像不來點人聲,電影就有失莊嚴而無神,那
不西不中的基調催生出一頭噪音怪獸,讓人視覺疲軟之餘,聽覺還被重複凌遲,難
怪有小道消息指出,公安部門已相中此曲,拷打訓問無不合適。
情節上,全是典型的激昂血淚,從【英雄】到【夜宴】,中國古裝始終如一的恩怨
情仇果真是絲毫未斷,張藝謀號稱的最終古裝巨作更是狗血盡灑、死命芭樂,從鬩
牆到亂倫,從殺妻到弒父,最後再來個虐子,真是台灣龍捲風、北京一起瘋。
所以,從視覺到聽覺,從聽覺到情節,從上到下,由內到外,本片真是時時有黃金
、處處有大便,大便可以來自重金,重金能讓大便看起來很高級,然而,大便就是
大便,不會因為灑上金粉、撲上花瓣後就變成真金。
其實,渴望華麗不是病、硬充莊嚴沒關係,至於龍捲風,中外王室本來就愛得要命
,問題是張大導老大不學好,寫了兩齣鬧劇被批爆、死到臨頭還覺悟不了,【夜宴
】的蠢斃遊戲才剛平息,張大導就迫不及待地為中國古裝片打出了最後一擊。
託他的福,原已奄奄一息的中國古裝片,如今終於壽終正寢、徹底死透,以後不論
誰想走這條老路,都不過是趕屍上路。
這種作品,如果再傳票房捷報、再來好評連場,豈不是昭告天下:身有黃金甲,天
塌都不怕,劇本不用好,有錢屌最大?搞到如此,才是豈有此理、人神共憤,所以
,真是不罵不行,不批無理!
最後,不斷地向西方拋媚眼的張藝謀,真的該學西方的吉伯遜老伯,人家粗裡粗氣
、看來缺乏導演造詣,可是【英雄本色】同樣是權謀、戰爭、龍捲風,成果卻平實
順暢、惹人感動,雖然服裝扮相骯髒,跟金甲裡面包大便一比還是很強!
而吉伯遜老伯原本還只是個動作演員呢!由此,原本專擅精緻小品的張大導,怎能
不去一趟勞改營,好好檢討檢討?
出處:http://www.wretch.cc/blog/woosean&article_id=5649543
--
文字是迷途者在黑森林中唯一的慰藉。
我的網誌:http://www.wretch.cc/blog/woosean
批兔個人板:SeanW
--
Tags:
電影
All Comments

By Faithe
at 2007-01-08T06:37
at 2007-01-08T06:37

By Ula
at 2007-01-12T22:32
at 2007-01-12T22:32

By Elvira
at 2007-01-15T09:26
at 2007-01-15T09:26

By Ophelia
at 2007-01-19T13:31
at 2007-01-19T13:31

By Daph Bay
at 2007-01-24T07:00
at 2007-01-24T07:00

By George
at 2007-01-25T14:23
at 2007-01-25T14:23

By Irma
at 2007-01-27T12:10
at 2007-01-27T12:10

By Ina
at 2007-01-29T21:39
at 2007-01-29T21:39

By Lauren
at 2007-02-03T04:45
at 2007-02-03T04:45

By Joe
at 2007-02-06T07:43
at 2007-02-06T07:43

By Adele
at 2007-02-11T04:26
at 2007-02-11T04:26

By Isla
at 2007-02-13T19:51
at 2007-02-13T19:51

By Lauren
at 2007-02-16T16:12
at 2007-02-16T16:12

By Lauren
at 2007-02-18T04:33
at 2007-02-18T04:33

By Necoo
at 2007-02-19T09:17
at 2007-02-19T09:17

By Yuri
at 2007-02-20T21:48
at 2007-02-20T21:48

By Joseph
at 2007-02-24T21:24
at 2007-02-24T21:24

By Oscar
at 2007-03-01T17:34
at 2007-03-01T17:34

By Connor
at 2007-03-04T13:39
at 2007-03-04T13:39

By Suhail Hany
at 2007-03-04T16:02
at 2007-03-04T16:02

By Harry
at 2007-03-08T21:50
at 2007-03-08T21:50

By Damian
at 2007-03-11T00:46
at 2007-03-11T00:46

By Brianna
at 2007-03-13T18:17
at 2007-03-13T18:17

By Rachel
at 2007-03-16T04:27
at 2007-03-16T04:27

By Eartha
at 2007-03-18T06:22
at 2007-03-18T06:22

By Skylar Davis
at 2007-03-20T10:36
at 2007-03-20T10:36

By Hamiltion
at 2007-03-22T15:31
at 2007-03-22T15:31

By Odelette
at 2007-03-26T04:47
at 2007-03-26T04:47

By Vanessa
at 2007-03-26T09:45
at 2007-03-26T09:45

By Quintina
at 2007-03-28T08:51
at 2007-03-28T08:51

By Regina
at 2007-03-31T17:38
at 2007-03-31T17:38

By Charlie
at 2007-04-01T13:51
at 2007-04-01T13:51

By Emily
at 2007-04-05T14:04
at 2007-04-05T14:04

By Audriana
at 2007-04-08T06:38
at 2007-04-08T06:38

By Eartha
at 2007-04-08T22:12
at 2007-04-08T22:12

By Christine
at 2007-04-13T05:49
at 2007-04-13T05:49

By Megan
at 2007-04-14T10:07
at 2007-04-14T10:07

By Valerie
at 2007-04-17T01:54
at 2007-04-17T01:54

By Jessica
at 2007-04-17T04:20
at 2007-04-17T04:20

By Kelly
at 2007-04-17T05:37
at 2007-04-17T05:37

By Mason
at 2007-04-21T01:15
at 2007-04-21T01:15

By Mason
at 2007-04-23T17:00
at 2007-04-23T17:00

By Jessica
at 2007-04-25T18:27
at 2007-04-25T18:27

By Tom
at 2007-04-28T22:40
at 2007-04-28T22:40

By Isabella
at 2007-04-29T03:18
at 2007-04-29T03:18

By Caroline
at 2007-05-01T16:49
at 2007-05-01T16:49

By Ivy
at 2007-05-06T13:31
at 2007-05-06T13:31

By Barb Cronin
at 2007-05-09T13:53
at 2007-05-09T13:53

By Lily
at 2007-05-13T19:48
at 2007-05-13T19:48

By Quanna
at 2007-05-14T20:43
at 2007-05-14T20:43

By Edith
at 2007-05-19T20:06
at 2007-05-19T20:06

By Dora
at 2007-05-24T11:53
at 2007-05-24T11:53

By Xanthe
at 2007-05-27T08:08
at 2007-05-27T08:08

By Jacob
at 2007-05-28T17:39
at 2007-05-28T17:39

By Doris
at 2007-05-29T08:36
at 2007-05-29T08:36

By Rachel
at 2007-05-30T08:57
at 2007-05-30T08:57

By Belly
at 2007-05-31T05:26
at 2007-05-31T05:26

By Iris
at 2007-06-03T16:46
at 2007-06-03T16:46

By Leila
at 2007-06-08T11:23
at 2007-06-08T11:23

By Linda
at 2007-06-08T18:08
at 2007-06-08T18:08

By Irma
at 2007-06-11T20:38
at 2007-06-11T20:38

By Sierra Rose
at 2007-06-15T00:09
at 2007-06-15T00:09

By Xanthe
at 2007-06-16T11:39
at 2007-06-16T11:39

By Ivy
at 2007-06-19T08:31
at 2007-06-19T08:31

By Tracy
at 2007-06-20T02:19
at 2007-06-20T02:19

By Ula
at 2007-06-21T23:03
at 2007-06-21T23:03

By Ina
at 2007-06-25T14:30
at 2007-06-25T14:30

By Daph Bay
at 2007-06-28T19:55
at 2007-06-28T19:55

By Sierra Rose
at 2007-07-01T02:29
at 2007-07-01T02:29

By Rachel
at 2007-07-01T05:10
at 2007-07-01T05:10

By Skylar DavisLinda
at 2007-07-03T21:21
at 2007-07-03T21:21

By Sandy
at 2007-07-06T09:10
at 2007-07-06T09:10

By Joseph
at 2007-07-10T02:44
at 2007-07-10T02:44

By Kyle
at 2007-07-10T13:03
at 2007-07-10T13:03

By Daph Bay
at 2007-07-13T22:56
at 2007-07-13T22:56

By Anonymous
at 2007-07-14T14:03
at 2007-07-14T14:03

By Frederic
at 2007-07-15T15:11
at 2007-07-15T15:11

By Regina
at 2007-07-19T09:04
at 2007-07-19T09:04

By Eartha
at 2007-07-22T03:41
at 2007-07-22T03:41

By Hedy
at 2007-07-23T00:44
at 2007-07-23T00:44

By Todd Johnson
at 2007-07-23T21:43
at 2007-07-23T21:43

By Kristin
at 2007-07-25T05:01
at 2007-07-25T05:01

By Agnes
at 2007-07-25T08:29
at 2007-07-25T08:29

By Agatha
at 2007-07-27T15:56
at 2007-07-27T15:56

By Zora
at 2007-07-30T10:31
at 2007-07-30T10:31

By Megan
at 2007-08-04T01:06
at 2007-08-04T01:06

By Ingrid
at 2007-08-05T07:26
at 2007-08-05T07:26

By Eden
at 2007-08-09T13:57
at 2007-08-09T13:57

By Charlotte
at 2007-08-12T12:44
at 2007-08-12T12:44

By Noah
at 2007-08-12T22:01
at 2007-08-12T22:01

By Andy
at 2007-08-13T22:51
at 2007-08-13T22:51

By Una
at 2007-08-16T17:28
at 2007-08-16T17:28

By Xanthe
at 2007-08-20T11:07
at 2007-08-20T11:07

By Zenobia
at 2007-08-20T20:32
at 2007-08-20T20:32

By Lucy
at 2007-08-23T17:39
at 2007-08-23T17:39

By Gilbert
at 2007-08-26T16:11
at 2007-08-26T16:11

By Audriana
at 2007-08-29T17:24
at 2007-08-29T17:24

By Ula
at 2007-08-31T15:59
at 2007-08-31T15:59

By Edwina
at 2007-09-01T10:22
at 2007-09-01T10:22

By Ophelia
at 2007-09-03T08:09
at 2007-09-03T08:09

By Puput
at 2007-09-06T12:22
at 2007-09-06T12:22

By Susan
at 2007-09-09T04:12
at 2007-09-09T04:12

By Sarah
at 2007-09-10T20:57
at 2007-09-10T20:57

By Necoo
at 2007-09-13T00:59
at 2007-09-13T00:59

By Dinah
at 2007-09-15T09:59
at 2007-09-15T09:59

By Sandy
at 2007-09-17T19:33
at 2007-09-17T19:33

By Dinah
at 2007-09-19T05:25
at 2007-09-19T05:25

By Valerie
at 2007-09-19T16:27
at 2007-09-19T16:27

By Emily
at 2007-09-21T10:06
at 2007-09-21T10:06

By Rachel
at 2007-09-23T12:09
at 2007-09-23T12:09

By Puput
at 2007-09-24T23:37
at 2007-09-24T23:37

By Yedda
at 2007-09-28T03:05
at 2007-09-28T03:05

By Ethan
at 2007-09-29T23:09
at 2007-09-29T23:09

By Cara
at 2007-10-01T22:20
at 2007-10-01T22:20

By Caroline
at 2007-10-02T09:43
at 2007-10-02T09:43

By Mary
at 2007-10-05T11:53
at 2007-10-05T11:53

By Hardy
at 2007-10-05T20:07
at 2007-10-05T20:07

By Hazel
at 2007-10-06T06:25
at 2007-10-06T06:25

By Ida
at 2007-10-11T01:52
at 2007-10-11T01:52

By Regina
at 2007-10-14T09:25
at 2007-10-14T09:25

By Zanna
at 2007-10-17T13:00
at 2007-10-17T13:00

By Daniel
at 2007-10-21T18:40
at 2007-10-21T18:40

By Emma
at 2007-10-24T21:40
at 2007-10-24T21:40

By Vanessa
at 2007-10-25T11:50
at 2007-10-25T11:50

By Ingrid
at 2007-10-26T18:38
at 2007-10-26T18:38

By Victoria
at 2007-10-28T06:56
at 2007-10-28T06:56

By Tracy
at 2007-10-30T21:11
at 2007-10-30T21:11

By Isla
at 2007-10-30T23:56
at 2007-10-30T23:56

By Caitlin
at 2007-11-01T09:35
at 2007-11-01T09:35

By Annie
at 2007-11-05T16:53
at 2007-11-05T16:53

By Kumar
at 2007-11-09T04:17
at 2007-11-09T04:17

By Daniel
at 2007-11-09T17:08
at 2007-11-09T17:08

By Hedy
at 2007-11-12T19:18
at 2007-11-12T19:18

By Zenobia
at 2007-11-14T07:47
at 2007-11-14T07:47

By Damian
at 2007-11-14T19:42
at 2007-11-14T19:42

By Aaliyah
at 2007-11-15T09:40
at 2007-11-15T09:40

By Enid
at 2007-11-17T01:22
at 2007-11-17T01:22

By Gilbert
at 2007-11-18T02:34
at 2007-11-18T02:34

By Yuri
at 2007-11-19T22:43
at 2007-11-19T22:43

By Heather
at 2007-11-22T09:49
at 2007-11-22T09:49

By Olive
at 2007-11-23T15:14
at 2007-11-23T15:14

By Queena
at 2007-11-25T18:07
at 2007-11-25T18:07

By Elma
at 2007-11-29T18:50
at 2007-11-29T18:50

By Skylar Davis
at 2007-12-02T14:06
at 2007-12-02T14:06

By Madame
at 2007-12-05T00:06
at 2007-12-05T00:06

By Barb Cronin
at 2007-12-08T09:32
at 2007-12-08T09:32

By Madame
at 2007-12-09T11:13
at 2007-12-09T11:13

By Eartha
at 2007-12-11T17:13
at 2007-12-11T17:13

By Una
at 2007-12-13T15:35
at 2007-12-13T15:35

By Poppy
at 2007-12-15T18:33
at 2007-12-15T18:33

By Iris
at 2007-12-17T06:34
at 2007-12-17T06:34

By Anonymous
at 2007-12-21T12:46
at 2007-12-21T12:46

By Hedwig
at 2007-12-23T11:18
at 2007-12-23T11:18

By Quintina
at 2007-12-26T20:28
at 2007-12-26T20:28

By Frederic
at 2007-12-28T21:06
at 2007-12-28T21:06

By Edward Lewis
at 2008-01-01T20:17
at 2008-01-01T20:17

By Poppy
at 2008-01-06T06:00
at 2008-01-06T06:00

By Barb Cronin
at 2008-01-11T00:44
at 2008-01-11T00:44

By Kyle
at 2008-01-15T04:46
at 2008-01-15T04:46

By Selena
at 2008-01-17T23:23
at 2008-01-17T23:23

By Edwina
at 2008-01-21T16:09
at 2008-01-21T16:09

By Isla
at 2008-01-26T13:53
at 2008-01-26T13:53

By Jessica
at 2008-01-27T16:34
at 2008-01-27T16:34

By Annie
at 2008-01-31T04:10
at 2008-01-31T04:10

By Rae
at 2008-02-03T00:18
at 2008-02-03T00:18

By Susan
at 2008-02-06T00:21
at 2008-02-06T00:21

By Kama
at 2008-02-07T13:05
at 2008-02-07T13:05

By Andrew
at 2008-02-08T19:04
at 2008-02-08T19:04

By Callum
at 2008-02-11T08:10
at 2008-02-11T08:10

By Robert
at 2008-02-13T01:56
at 2008-02-13T01:56

By Doris
at 2008-02-14T11:36
at 2008-02-14T11:36
Related Posts
《傷城》

By Hardy
at 2007-01-03T21:04
at 2007-01-03T21:04
《愛情,不用翻譯》by(時光之硯)

By Dorothy
at 2007-01-02T21:33
at 2007-01-02T21:33
《芭樂特》:真人版的鱉四與大頭蛋大鬧美國行

By William
at 2007-01-02T16:40
at 2007-01-02T16:40
20年老經典「機器戰警 ROBOCOP」

By Leila
at 2007-01-02T09:03
at 2007-01-02T09:03
心得:最後一次心動

By Irma
at 2007-01-02T00:07
at 2007-01-02T00:07