隋唐演義之你在堅持什麼啦 - 陸劇
By Noah
at 2013-04-26T02:20
at 2013-04-26T02:20
Table of Contents
看完《隋唐演義》,本劇優缺點很明顯,
前面各位板友live文已多次討論,此處就不再贅述綜合心得,
本文只針對劇中之"堅持"這部份的劇情聊述個人感想。
不知怎的,俺對於《隋唐演義》這部劇,印象特別深刻的是
幾位角色的「堅持」:
堅持"政治立場":
劇中幾位長輩級的角色,如靠山王楊林、北平王羅藝、一字長蛇陣專家丁延平
雖然明知隋煬帝楊廣荒淫+暴政+得位不正,
且在朝中遭到奸相宇文化及的打壓陷害,
但面對晚輩們苦勸另投明主時,均一面倒的加以拒絕,堅持忠於當權者。
此心態其實可以理解,如果你家裡或生活週遭,
有政治狂熱者或被政治教育洗腦很徹底的親友,
例如深藍、深綠、或是北韓人之類....
他們的腦子裡終其一生只看得見自己認同的政治理念,
其它任何不同於自己信仰的政治團體都是屁,都是反賊。
對於自己認同的政權,縱使有再大的問題,
他們只會希望在體制內改革,例如換個新宰相,換個同樣姓楊的當皇帝
腦子裡從沒想過推翻當權者另立新君,例如接受李家或其它反王勢力來統治自己
這種根深蒂固的政治認同,就算面前跪了一千個晚輩也無法扭轉。
無法面對與接受新時代新局勢,溫和點就像許多民初劇裡留妹妹頭的滿清遺老,
激烈的就像本劇這幾位阿伯,以自身捍衛信仰與理念,戰至生命最後一刻。
堅持"感情":
本劇最痴情角色當然非宇文成都莫屬,對楊玉兒的真誠專一的感情,
令人瞠目結舌。
雖然編劇沒有舖排前因,觀眾不知道他跟楊玉兒之間有什麼過去,
讓他如此情根深種;
編劇也沒有舖排中途發展,從有劇以來,楊玉兒從未為宇文成都付出過,
一滴眼淚、一句憐惜的話、幫他擋子彈、餵他喝粥喝藥等戲劇常用梗從未出現,
只見宇文成都不斷為楊玉兒付出,一再搭救、一再解危,
楊玉兒不但從不感激,還一直結賽面給宇文成都看,
甚至直接烙狠話「我從沒喜歡過你,你死心吧」
宇文成都在感情路上被楊玉兒這面壁碰得不但是滿頭包,
甚至可說已到血流滿面的地步,但這傢伙還是不離不棄,
雖然可以理解,但還是很想問他老兄「你到底在堅持什麼?」
堅持"原則":
單雄信全家被李淵滅門,此後單雄信總不忘殺李家人以報被滅門之仇。
最後當他知道殺李家人乃不可能完成之任務後,
堅持要李世民公開處死他。
就算眾兄弟在他面前痛哭流涕如喪考妣,他也不改初衷。
單雄信的心情相信觀眾都懂,畢竟全家一兩百口的性命白白葬送,
任誰也無法背負著這沉重的情感包袱,在"敵人"之下高官厚祿的過完餘生。
可是:
一、李淵當初是奉命而行,真正下格殺令的是統治者楊廣與宇文化及。
二、後來單雄信有了新家庭,妻弱子幼需要扶養。
三、眾結義兄弟一起為他向李世民求情,連李世民都在他面前跪了兩次,
求他原諒及放下往日冤仇。
四、若真要殺死李家父子,有很多方法,不是非得這麼明刀明槍的幹。
如果幹不來假依順真伺機而動,也可以隱姓埋名當刺客。
綜合以上,俺看不懂單雄信是在堅持個啥?非得公開斬首才爽?
後面刑場眾兄弟相送,單雄信還真有點人來瘋的味道,
越勸、越哭、他越來勁,一副慷慨就義的烈士模樣,
口說「不事二主」,自己事了程咬金李密王世充;
指責尉遲恭「賣主求榮」,尉遲恭也跟你一樣全家被殺,仇人還更貨真價實呢!
講的話都在打自己臉;
兄弟送行大小眼,小咖如李如輝、齊國遠的酒還不怎麼想喝;
思考邏輯很奇怪,指責妖道帶走秦瓊、程咬金,「連羅成都不留給我!」
那61集開頭盈盈說「其實是我哥讓我來勸你的」又算怎麼回事?
如果單雄信沒表態,羅成怎麼可能拋下盈盈,走得那麼乾脆?
小心眼深記舊仇,臨死前不忘還吐羅成當初在賈柳樓門口的那口痰,
羅成說「哥哥,你我來世再做兄弟」,他老兄抬頭望天滿臉不屑。
臨刑前單雄信長嘆:「都說桃園三結義,哪個相交到白頭?」
兄弟交不到白頭,最大的問題是在於老兄你吧!
用這樣一個人物之死,做為全劇結尾,表面上看起來令人唏噓感嘆,
深究起來會跟尤俊達一樣滿臉三條線啊!
單雄信你是在堅持什麼啦!!! XD
--
前面各位板友live文已多次討論,此處就不再贅述綜合心得,
本文只針對劇中之"堅持"這部份的劇情聊述個人感想。
不知怎的,俺對於《隋唐演義》這部劇,印象特別深刻的是
幾位角色的「堅持」:
堅持"政治立場":
劇中幾位長輩級的角色,如靠山王楊林、北平王羅藝、一字長蛇陣專家丁延平
雖然明知隋煬帝楊廣荒淫+暴政+得位不正,
且在朝中遭到奸相宇文化及的打壓陷害,
但面對晚輩們苦勸另投明主時,均一面倒的加以拒絕,堅持忠於當權者。
此心態其實可以理解,如果你家裡或生活週遭,
有政治狂熱者或被政治教育洗腦很徹底的親友,
例如深藍、深綠、或是北韓人之類....
他們的腦子裡終其一生只看得見自己認同的政治理念,
其它任何不同於自己信仰的政治團體都是屁,都是反賊。
對於自己認同的政權,縱使有再大的問題,
他們只會希望在體制內改革,例如換個新宰相,換個同樣姓楊的當皇帝
腦子裡從沒想過推翻當權者另立新君,例如接受李家或其它反王勢力來統治自己
這種根深蒂固的政治認同,就算面前跪了一千個晚輩也無法扭轉。
無法面對與接受新時代新局勢,溫和點就像許多民初劇裡留妹妹頭的滿清遺老,
激烈的就像本劇這幾位阿伯,以自身捍衛信仰與理念,戰至生命最後一刻。
堅持"感情":
本劇最痴情角色當然非宇文成都莫屬,對楊玉兒的真誠專一的感情,
令人瞠目結舌。
雖然編劇沒有舖排前因,觀眾不知道他跟楊玉兒之間有什麼過去,
讓他如此情根深種;
編劇也沒有舖排中途發展,從有劇以來,楊玉兒從未為宇文成都付出過,
一滴眼淚、一句憐惜的話、幫他擋子彈、餵他喝粥喝藥等戲劇常用梗從未出現,
只見宇文成都不斷為楊玉兒付出,一再搭救、一再解危,
楊玉兒不但從不感激,還一直結賽面給宇文成都看,
甚至直接烙狠話「我從沒喜歡過你,你死心吧」
宇文成都在感情路上被楊玉兒這面壁碰得不但是滿頭包,
甚至可說已到血流滿面的地步,但這傢伙還是不離不棄,
雖然可以理解,但還是很想問他老兄「你到底在堅持什麼?」
堅持"原則":
單雄信全家被李淵滅門,此後單雄信總不忘殺李家人以報被滅門之仇。
最後當他知道殺李家人乃不可能完成之任務後,
堅持要李世民公開處死他。
就算眾兄弟在他面前痛哭流涕如喪考妣,他也不改初衷。
單雄信的心情相信觀眾都懂,畢竟全家一兩百口的性命白白葬送,
任誰也無法背負著這沉重的情感包袱,在"敵人"之下高官厚祿的過完餘生。
可是:
一、李淵當初是奉命而行,真正下格殺令的是統治者楊廣與宇文化及。
二、後來單雄信有了新家庭,妻弱子幼需要扶養。
三、眾結義兄弟一起為他向李世民求情,連李世民都在他面前跪了兩次,
求他原諒及放下往日冤仇。
四、若真要殺死李家父子,有很多方法,不是非得這麼明刀明槍的幹。
如果幹不來假依順真伺機而動,也可以隱姓埋名當刺客。
綜合以上,俺看不懂單雄信是在堅持個啥?非得公開斬首才爽?
後面刑場眾兄弟相送,單雄信還真有點人來瘋的味道,
越勸、越哭、他越來勁,一副慷慨就義的烈士模樣,
口說「不事二主」,自己事了程咬金李密王世充;
指責尉遲恭「賣主求榮」,尉遲恭也跟你一樣全家被殺,仇人還更貨真價實呢!
講的話都在打自己臉;
兄弟送行大小眼,小咖如李如輝、齊國遠的酒還不怎麼想喝;
思考邏輯很奇怪,指責妖道帶走秦瓊、程咬金,「連羅成都不留給我!」
那61集開頭盈盈說「其實是我哥讓我來勸你的」又算怎麼回事?
如果單雄信沒表態,羅成怎麼可能拋下盈盈,走得那麼乾脆?
小心眼深記舊仇,臨死前不忘還吐羅成當初在賈柳樓門口的那口痰,
羅成說「哥哥,你我來世再做兄弟」,他老兄抬頭望天滿臉不屑。
臨刑前單雄信長嘆:「都說桃園三結義,哪個相交到白頭?」
兄弟交不到白頭,最大的問題是在於老兄你吧!
用這樣一個人物之死,做為全劇結尾,表面上看起來令人唏噓感嘆,
深究起來會跟尤俊達一樣滿臉三條線啊!
單雄信你是在堅持什麼啦!!! XD
--
Tags:
陸劇
All Comments
By Joseph
at 2013-04-28T10:38
at 2013-04-28T10:38
By Sandy
at 2013-04-30T04:41
at 2013-04-30T04:41
By Michael
at 2013-05-04T23:44
at 2013-05-04T23:44
By Ida
at 2013-05-05T11:20
at 2013-05-05T11:20
By Annie
at 2013-05-07T01:19
at 2013-05-07T01:19
By Tristan Cohan
at 2013-05-09T13:34
at 2013-05-09T13:34
By Sarah
at 2013-05-13T07:58
at 2013-05-13T07:58
By Joseph
at 2013-05-17T19:20
at 2013-05-17T19:20
By Yuri
at 2013-05-18T13:55
at 2013-05-18T13:55
By Heather
at 2013-05-21T12:57
at 2013-05-21T12:57
By Sarah
at 2013-05-23T00:46
at 2013-05-23T00:46
By Enid
at 2013-05-23T04:58
at 2013-05-23T04:58
By Dora
at 2013-05-25T23:16
at 2013-05-25T23:16
By Hardy
at 2013-05-26T05:36
at 2013-05-26T05:36
By Charlotte
at 2013-05-27T20:38
at 2013-05-27T20:38
By Barb Cronin
at 2013-05-31T16:11
at 2013-05-31T16:11
By Frederic
at 2013-06-04T12:53
at 2013-06-04T12:53
By Blanche
at 2013-06-08T23:52
at 2013-06-08T23:52
By Iris
at 2013-06-13T09:36
at 2013-06-13T09:36
By Christine
at 2013-06-16T08:55
at 2013-06-16T08:55
By Xanthe
at 2013-06-17T11:44
at 2013-06-17T11:44
By William
at 2013-06-18T07:14
at 2013-06-18T07:14
By Selena
at 2013-06-19T00:11
at 2013-06-19T00:11
By Eartha
at 2013-06-19T07:11
at 2013-06-19T07:11
By Poppy
at 2013-06-20T05:15
at 2013-06-20T05:15
By Aaliyah
at 2013-06-24T17:30
at 2013-06-24T17:30
By Wallis
at 2013-06-27T03:05
at 2013-06-27T03:05
By Genevieve
at 2013-07-01T04:46
at 2013-07-01T04:46
By Blanche
at 2013-07-03T02:23
at 2013-07-03T02:23
By Mary
at 2013-07-06T17:44
at 2013-07-06T17:44
By Heather
at 2013-07-09T04:17
at 2013-07-09T04:17
By Quanna
at 2013-07-12T19:16
at 2013-07-12T19:16
By Valerie
at 2013-07-14T16:59
at 2013-07-14T16:59
By Isabella
at 2013-07-15T18:09
at 2013-07-15T18:09
By Daph Bay
at 2013-07-20T15:09
at 2013-07-20T15:09
By Caroline
at 2013-07-22T07:25
at 2013-07-22T07:25
By Megan
at 2013-07-27T00:24
at 2013-07-27T00:24
By Oliver
at 2013-07-29T01:03
at 2013-07-29T01:03
By Damian
at 2013-07-29T05:30
at 2013-07-29T05:30
By Puput
at 2013-07-29T08:19
at 2013-07-29T08:19
By Jessica
at 2013-07-31T16:12
at 2013-07-31T16:12
By Edith
at 2013-08-04T07:05
at 2013-08-04T07:05
By Mary
at 2013-08-08T18:54
at 2013-08-08T18:54
By Jack
at 2013-08-08T23:46
at 2013-08-08T23:46
By Margaret
at 2013-08-09T08:58
at 2013-08-09T08:58
By Zenobia
at 2013-08-10T07:52
at 2013-08-10T07:52
By Ida
at 2013-08-12T01:38
at 2013-08-12T01:38
By Thomas
at 2013-08-15T06:52
at 2013-08-15T06:52
By Damian
at 2013-08-16T22:40
at 2013-08-16T22:40
By Dora
at 2013-08-19T06:32
at 2013-08-19T06:32
By William
at 2013-08-23T14:28
at 2013-08-23T14:28
By Andrew
at 2013-08-25T00:08
at 2013-08-25T00:08
By Hazel
at 2013-08-28T08:57
at 2013-08-28T08:57
By Mary
at 2013-08-28T15:48
at 2013-08-28T15:48
By Olivia
at 2013-08-29T04:27
at 2013-08-29T04:27
By Mary
at 2013-09-02T23:26
at 2013-09-02T23:26
By Bennie
at 2013-09-07T20:18
at 2013-09-07T20:18
By Daniel
at 2013-09-08T00:14
at 2013-09-08T00:14
By Yuri
at 2013-09-09T19:04
at 2013-09-09T19:04
By Franklin
at 2013-09-14T18:58
at 2013-09-14T18:58
By Regina
at 2013-09-15T23:01
at 2013-09-15T23:01
By Dorothy
at 2013-09-16T05:41
at 2013-09-16T05:41
By Lauren
at 2013-09-17T10:49
at 2013-09-17T10:49
By Annie
at 2013-09-17T15:20
at 2013-09-17T15:20
By Edwina
at 2013-09-20T02:38
at 2013-09-20T02:38
By Regina
at 2013-09-23T13:54
at 2013-09-23T13:54
By Puput
at 2013-09-24T22:03
at 2013-09-24T22:03
By Jacky
at 2013-09-25T08:50
at 2013-09-25T08:50
By Adele
at 2013-09-29T08:56
at 2013-09-29T08:56
By Erin
at 2013-09-30T04:23
at 2013-09-30T04:23
By Zanna
at 2013-09-30T23:05
at 2013-09-30T23:05
By Yuri
at 2013-10-02T09:36
at 2013-10-02T09:36
By Bethany
at 2013-10-04T17:50
at 2013-10-04T17:50
By Queena
at 2013-10-07T14:02
at 2013-10-07T14:02
By Xanthe
at 2013-10-09T09:02
at 2013-10-09T09:02
By Isla
at 2013-10-12T05:36
at 2013-10-12T05:36
By Dorothy
at 2013-10-13T10:45
at 2013-10-13T10:45
By George
at 2013-10-13T15:24
at 2013-10-13T15:24
By Todd Johnson
at 2013-10-16T19:36
at 2013-10-16T19:36
By Delia
at 2013-10-18T23:02
at 2013-10-18T23:02
By Anonymous
at 2013-10-22T14:50
at 2013-10-22T14:50
By Leila
at 2013-10-26T14:51
at 2013-10-26T14:51
By Audriana
at 2013-10-28T12:41
at 2013-10-28T12:41
By Blanche
at 2013-10-29T05:57
at 2013-10-29T05:57
By Erin
at 2013-11-01T06:25
at 2013-11-01T06:25
By Mia
at 2013-11-04T17:57
at 2013-11-04T17:57
By Audriana
at 2013-11-09T02:28
at 2013-11-09T02:28
By Lydia
at 2013-11-12T08:32
at 2013-11-12T08:32
By Steve
at 2013-11-14T19:50
at 2013-11-14T19:50
By Jacob
at 2013-11-19T06:36
at 2013-11-19T06:36
By Andrew
at 2013-11-23T18:07
at 2013-11-23T18:07
By Yedda
at 2013-11-28T04:31
at 2013-11-28T04:31
By Hardy
at 2013-11-29T07:29
at 2013-11-29T07:29
By Mia
at 2013-11-30T21:37
at 2013-11-30T21:37
By Skylar DavisLinda
at 2013-12-02T18:08
at 2013-12-02T18:08
By Bennie
at 2013-12-05T23:08
at 2013-12-05T23:08
By Daph Bay
at 2013-12-08T21:37
at 2013-12-08T21:37
By Annie
at 2013-12-12T21:48
at 2013-12-12T21:48
By Cara
at 2013-12-13T08:39
at 2013-12-13T08:39
By Rachel
at 2013-12-14T23:49
at 2013-12-14T23:49
By Susan
at 2013-12-19T01:18
at 2013-12-19T01:18
By Zora
at 2013-12-22T11:50
at 2013-12-22T11:50
Related Posts
英雄 第三集
By Zanna
at 2013-04-25T19:56
at 2013-04-25T19:56
隋唐演義DVD 將於月底發行
By Jacky
at 2013-04-24T23:48
at 2013-04-24T23:48
英雄第二集
By Freda
at 2013-04-24T19:30
at 2013-04-24T19:30
4月大陸新劇上星--《新編輯部故事》
By Dinah
at 2013-04-24T19:26
at 2013-04-24T19:26
隋唐演義觀後感
By Eden
at 2013-04-24T19:10
at 2013-04-24T19:10