實在看不懂全面啟動 - 電影
By Harry
at 2010-08-04T18:08
at 2010-08-04T18:08
Table of Contents
我給個觀點好了,雖然是個很主觀的觀點。
簡單一句話:你認為Inception是什麼,它就是什麼。
高行健的諾貝爾得獎詞有一段我非常喜歡的話:「說佛在你心中,不如說自由在你心中」
你想相信什麼就相信什麼,不信什麼別人說再多也沒用。
同理,有的電影並不訴諸於「傳達訊息」,而是將事情講的曖昧不明,提供觀賞者一個
自省的機會。
這和明確傳達創作者思想的作品不同在於,前者是創作者將心力投注在創造一個世界,
然後將這個世界分享給其他人,人能從其中自己找到想要的東西,後者則是創作者個人
的發聲,我們只能聆聽,然後決定自己接不接受。
我不敢說哪個比較好,但可以確定的是,前者比後者更難以達成。有不少問題作都著眼
於此,但這些作品,我舉動畫當例子,如EVA、攻殼機動隊innocence等只能被稱為
「問題作」而不是肯定的「好」或是「壞」,因為觀賞者的評價太過兩極,好的認為壞
的缺乏理解的必要知識,壞的認為好的過度解讀,究竟誰是誰非根本不可能有解答。
所以今天Inception的出現才更顯重要,它創造了一個或許不是所有人,但至少大多數人
都能進入並且探索自己渴望的世界。注意,我認為創造一個可供思辯的世界並不等同於
客觀,完全的客觀只存在於科學,所以與其說這是一種客觀的作法,不如說是創作者將自
己的想法具現化以後「分享」給我們。
所以到頭來,我們根本沒有辦法肯定Inception真正的訊息為何,但這個世界本來就是灰色
而不是黑或白,能肯定的,只是導演兼編劇的Christopher Nolan做了一個好夢,進入
電影院的過程無非也是一場盜夢的過程,但最後我什麼明確的訊息都沒偷到,我只是跟費
雪一樣,被Inception了,至於被植入的想法是什麼,只有我們自己能確定。
--
簡單一句話:你認為Inception是什麼,它就是什麼。
高行健的諾貝爾得獎詞有一段我非常喜歡的話:「說佛在你心中,不如說自由在你心中」
你想相信什麼就相信什麼,不信什麼別人說再多也沒用。
同理,有的電影並不訴諸於「傳達訊息」,而是將事情講的曖昧不明,提供觀賞者一個
自省的機會。
這和明確傳達創作者思想的作品不同在於,前者是創作者將心力投注在創造一個世界,
然後將這個世界分享給其他人,人能從其中自己找到想要的東西,後者則是創作者個人
的發聲,我們只能聆聽,然後決定自己接不接受。
我不敢說哪個比較好,但可以確定的是,前者比後者更難以達成。有不少問題作都著眼
於此,但這些作品,我舉動畫當例子,如EVA、攻殼機動隊innocence等只能被稱為
「問題作」而不是肯定的「好」或是「壞」,因為觀賞者的評價太過兩極,好的認為壞
的缺乏理解的必要知識,壞的認為好的過度解讀,究竟誰是誰非根本不可能有解答。
所以今天Inception的出現才更顯重要,它創造了一個或許不是所有人,但至少大多數人
都能進入並且探索自己渴望的世界。注意,我認為創造一個可供思辯的世界並不等同於
客觀,完全的客觀只存在於科學,所以與其說這是一種客觀的作法,不如說是創作者將自
己的想法具現化以後「分享」給我們。
所以到頭來,我們根本沒有辦法肯定Inception真正的訊息為何,但這個世界本來就是灰色
而不是黑或白,能肯定的,只是導演兼編劇的Christopher Nolan做了一個好夢,進入
電影院的過程無非也是一場盜夢的過程,但最後我什麼明確的訊息都沒偷到,我只是跟費
雪一樣,被Inception了,至於被植入的想法是什麼,只有我們自己能確定。
--
Tags:
電影
All Comments
By Victoria
at 2010-08-08T13:13
at 2010-08-08T13:13
By Andy
at 2010-08-11T11:15
at 2010-08-11T11:15
By Mia
at 2010-08-15T09:05
at 2010-08-15T09:05
By Aaliyah
at 2010-08-17T01:00
at 2010-08-17T01:00
By Andy
at 2010-08-18T17:04
at 2010-08-18T17:04
By Charlie
at 2010-08-22T20:42
at 2010-08-22T20:42
By Wallis
at 2010-08-26T05:26
at 2010-08-26T05:26
By Rebecca
at 2010-08-30T23:50
at 2010-08-30T23:50
By Poppy
at 2010-08-31T02:17
at 2010-08-31T02:17
By Adele
at 2010-09-01T10:50
at 2010-09-01T10:50
By Skylar DavisLinda
at 2010-09-02T02:20
at 2010-09-02T02:20
By Barb Cronin
at 2010-09-06T00:41
at 2010-09-06T00:41
By Christine
at 2010-09-07T11:38
at 2010-09-07T11:38
By Agatha
at 2010-09-09T09:55
at 2010-09-09T09:55
By Hedwig
at 2010-09-10T08:37
at 2010-09-10T08:37
By Olga
at 2010-09-13T09:28
at 2010-09-13T09:28
By Frederic
at 2010-09-14T07:54
at 2010-09-14T07:54
By Carol
at 2010-09-14T21:13
at 2010-09-14T21:13
By Thomas
at 2010-09-16T14:42
at 2010-09-16T14:42
By Thomas
at 2010-09-19T04:34
at 2010-09-19T04:34
By Oliver
at 2010-09-24T02:53
at 2010-09-24T02:53
By Robert
at 2010-09-25T12:25
at 2010-09-25T12:25
By Gary
at 2010-09-29T06:56
at 2010-09-29T06:56
By Xanthe
at 2010-10-02T20:00
at 2010-10-02T20:00
By Cara
at 2010-10-03T06:14
at 2010-10-03T06:14
By Irma
at 2010-10-03T17:08
at 2010-10-03T17:08
By Michael
at 2010-10-04T18:45
at 2010-10-04T18:45
By Belly
at 2010-10-05T19:19
at 2010-10-05T19:19
By Sierra Rose
at 2010-10-08T18:24
at 2010-10-08T18:24
By Olive
at 2010-10-10T20:42
at 2010-10-10T20:42
By Ina
at 2010-10-12T04:54
at 2010-10-12T04:54
By George
at 2010-10-12T21:30
at 2010-10-12T21:30
By Emma
at 2010-10-17T04:34
at 2010-10-17T04:34
By Oscar
at 2010-10-19T04:59
at 2010-10-19T04:59
By Dorothy
at 2010-10-22T20:28
at 2010-10-22T20:28
By Robert
at 2010-10-26T15:45
at 2010-10-26T15:45
By Ethan
at 2010-10-26T17:15
at 2010-10-26T17:15
By Tom
at 2010-10-29T13:48
at 2010-10-29T13:48
By Kyle
at 2010-10-29T20:04
at 2010-10-29T20:04
By Iris
at 2010-11-03T19:32
at 2010-11-03T19:32
By Eden
at 2010-11-07T12:16
at 2010-11-07T12:16
By Puput
at 2010-11-08T20:19
at 2010-11-08T20:19
By Emily
at 2010-11-12T21:59
at 2010-11-12T21:59
By Edwina
at 2010-11-14T11:52
at 2010-11-14T11:52
By Frederic
at 2010-11-19T03:26
at 2010-11-19T03:26
By James
at 2010-11-23T04:25
at 2010-11-23T04:25
By James
at 2010-11-27T15:23
at 2010-11-27T15:23
By Dorothy
at 2010-11-30T10:30
at 2010-11-30T10:30
By Audriana
at 2010-11-30T11:34
at 2010-11-30T11:34
By Lydia
at 2010-11-30T19:18
at 2010-11-30T19:18
By Mia
at 2010-12-02T11:41
at 2010-12-02T11:41
By Yuri
at 2010-12-03T12:16
at 2010-12-03T12:16
By Xanthe
at 2010-12-04T20:13
at 2010-12-04T20:13
By Belly
at 2010-12-07T19:40
at 2010-12-07T19:40
By Rae
at 2010-12-09T10:37
at 2010-12-09T10:37
By Oscar
at 2010-12-11T09:00
at 2010-12-11T09:00
By Blanche
at 2010-12-13T01:50
at 2010-12-13T01:50
By Noah
at 2010-12-14T15:35
at 2010-12-14T15:35
By Margaret
at 2010-12-14T22:03
at 2010-12-14T22:03
By William
at 2010-12-19T14:57
at 2010-12-19T14:57
By Regina
at 2010-12-24T02:08
at 2010-12-24T02:08
By Catherine
at 2010-12-24T20:13
at 2010-12-24T20:13
By Daph Bay
at 2010-12-26T00:27
at 2010-12-26T00:27
By Necoo
at 2010-12-29T13:50
at 2010-12-29T13:50
By Hedy
at 2011-01-02T08:43
at 2011-01-02T08:43
By Delia
at 2011-01-03T16:21
at 2011-01-03T16:21
By Rosalind
at 2011-01-05T07:37
at 2011-01-05T07:37
By Olivia
at 2011-01-09T21:42
at 2011-01-09T21:42
By Donna
at 2011-01-13T14:44
at 2011-01-13T14:44
By Ursula
at 2011-01-18T14:14
at 2011-01-18T14:14
By Noah
at 2011-01-19T09:49
at 2011-01-19T09:49
By Eartha
at 2011-01-22T17:49
at 2011-01-22T17:49
By John
at 2011-01-25T20:31
at 2011-01-25T20:31
By Callum
at 2011-01-28T04:28
at 2011-01-28T04:28
Related Posts
尼可拉斯凱吉歷年電影票房,IMDB
By Carol
at 2010-08-02T23:41
at 2010-08-02T23:41
人工進化切身觀後感
By Elvira
at 2010-08-01T15:32
at 2010-08-01T15:32
惡搞創意無限-人工進化
By William
at 2010-07-30T16:22
at 2010-07-30T16:22
【電影隨筆】談《全面啟動》(Inception)
By Charlie
at 2010-07-30T15:06
at 2010-07-30T15:06
聊聊Inception的角色塑造與敘事手法
By Olive
at 2010-07-30T12:58
at 2010-07-30T12:58